If your Sandy's is a Kroger brand store, you might try their deluxe ice cream brands. I am a huge fan of Blue Bell (don't even go there about the recent brouhaha) and not being able to get it here in VA, I have found Kroger's brand to be a close second. I LOVE their peppermint!! If you CAN get it, ask for it to be carried all year; mine responded positively to my request.
Jan in VA