Do what ever your heart directs you to do! I have some tops like that" some really ugly,mixture of fabrics,odd sizes,badly pieced, etc." I've redone two, after the first one, I said never again!!! After the second one, I said, never again!!!!But I can't seem to let go of them. When I get them out to throw them away, I start to think about the quilter who made them and the story behind them. God, help me, I've got two more in various stages of remake!!! Never again!!!