I think guild shows should just be eye candy for the world.......no judging, either "pro" or viewers (see Jan's comment on that).
Another bit of disillusionment lately is county fairs---at least the few I've been too. Some items that have won blues are no where near what should be called be "the best".... But in questioning that, was told...ribbons have to be given, even though the item may not really be worthy..."state law"????? Interesting. My thinking would be if the only offerings in a category are blatantly not good work, then no ribbon in that category should be awarded...not the case.....