Krista, if it were me and I didn't know quite what to do yet, take an easy one out of the pile, do it, leave this beautiful one hanging out so you can look at it as you walk by, but be sure you can see it. Then, bam, an inspiration will hit you. The Lisa Calle designing is fun and you can get inspiration that way. Also, do a little pintrest searching for the pattern and you will see something. That is what I have to do at times to get moving on a quilting project. Or you can do the stencil search and look at quilting ideas. Is it "What to quilt" that is getting you? DO you feel it is not finished pieced? I like the border idea that was presented.
Alas, I am a bit stuck as well. I ended up with two drunkard path quilts. Found two different layouts, they are sewn but now to find a border for one. I also need some time to design the quilting on 18" squares. Yep, they ended up that big. Think I will go and search out some stencil designs that might work.