Both would be good, but the Janome probably has more harp space. I've found Brothers to be more limited in that . Have you tried the Janome 8900? It has 2 inches more throat which makes a huge difference. I love the auto tension and how quiet it is. But the Skyline is quiet, too. Not sure what the Brother is like. I'd encourage you to try the 8200 or 8900 (I have the 8200 and LOVE LOVE LOVE it--it's less money than the 89) .