My first paper piecing was from a Judy Niemeyer pattern, but I made it in conjunction with a class. I've since made quilts from her patterns with no real problems, other than trying to figure out which fabric corresponds to which pieces in the pattern. Once you know how to paper piece, the detailed directions in a pattern are not as necessary. She does give sizes for cutting the fabric pieces, which is very helpful. I have never done a Carol Doak pattern, but I have heard that her patterns and her books are easier to follow.