Ok after all of the wonderful help I got with which one to make, don't you know that my friend chose the very last one I posted! Grrrr, all that work.
I have been sending her (who I am secretly making it for) the pics too and she chose this one.
Can ya believe it? So I guess this one wins this round and if I have enough fabric left, I'll do one of the others.
Thank you EVERYONE for your imputs, they me so much to me!
the chosen one
[ATTACH=CONFIG]26213[/ATTACH]