The decal was original to the machine, which was not a singer. I don't know what it was finished with. I had assumed it was shellac. Here is a picture of what I am dealing with. First picture is of the damaged decal, second picture is an undamaged decal.
[ATTACH=CONFIG]589048[/ATTACH]
[ATTACH=CONFIG]589049[/ATTACH]
Another option I have been considering is finding someone who does sewing machine decals and asking for a custom decal of just this damaged piece.