I also use my runners/toppers throughout the house, so I would love to receive either of them! One caution though - if Caroline has to sort out who made what, in what shaped & would like to receive which shape - that's a whole lot of work added for her! We don't want her to go on strike!
Makers choice is a good time/challenge to do something a little different, without adding additional workload to our leader. Would that work? I'm in for whatever shape, size the team chooses. . Oops! not quite, no hand embroidery please, I haven't done that since I was 14! lol