Yep, the freezer paper gets too soggy to reuse easily. I was thinking that it would work better if both sides were plastic and I tried a piece with the freezer paper facing the other way (gluing it to the fabric instead of ironing it on) and it did come off more easily but the overall process still didn’t work as well as I would like. I think the idea (from Peckish and junegerbracht— thanks to you both) of the plastic templates would work well for me for when I have a shape that I want to make multiple times. I’ll try that out the next time I have something that repeats. Thanks!