Opinions/Thoughts re: Swaps and Robins?
10-22-2011, 01:40 PM
#61
Super Member
Join Date: Mar 2007
Location: Here and there
Posts: 1,669
Originally Posted by dixiechunk
I can only answer with reference to the Row Round Robin I participated in with my quilt guild. Each of us was given a number, chose a theme and made a row. We put our completed row in a brown paper bag with any specific instructions or extra fabric from our row for others to use
for continuity. Each month (at guild meeting) we passed our bags to the next number in sequence til it came back to the owner. The only big "rule" was you couldn't show anyone the quilt-in-progress to anyone. You had to wait til the end at show and tell.
One lady did an applique cat row. Someone else did a red hat theme. Mine was a Maryland theme...crabs, sunflowers, ocean waves. Everyone got their quilt back and seemed delighted. One lady who wanted to play but didn't feel like she could commit offered to act as "design consultant" for participants who needed some help coming up with ideas. She was the only one who was allowed a preview peek.
How do round robins/row robins work? froggyintexas
for continuity. Each month (at guild meeting) we passed our bags to the next number in sequence til it came back to the owner. The only big "rule" was you couldn't show anyone the quilt-in-progress to anyone. You had to wait til the end at show and tell.
One lady did an applique cat row. Someone else did a red hat theme. Mine was a Maryland theme...crabs, sunflowers, ocean waves. Everyone got their quilt back and seemed delighted. One lady who wanted to play but didn't feel like she could commit offered to act as "design consultant" for participants who needed some help coming up with ideas. She was the only one who was allowed a preview peek.
Originally Posted by FroggyinTexas
Originally Posted by Mad Mimm
I am considering trying a swap or Row/Round Robin and have never done one before. I was curious what experience my fellow quilters have had with these? Good/Bad, were you happy with the experience, what did you learn? Also, any advice for a newbie who is nervous about "taking the plunge?" Thanks in advance! :-)
10-22-2011, 05:23 PM
#63
Super Member
Join Date: May 2007
Location: New Zealand
Posts: 1,851
I have done a row robin with three good friends who also quilt. That quilt is very special to me and does bring great memories of my friendships back when I look at it. We did it over about 8 months I think and we kept a journal of our thoughts and what we decided to do etc and why so that had special meaning also and is fun to read back on. I recommend you set yourself some goal to achieve. If it is new colour ways to work with it is a good exercise for that. If you want it to be more personal then do it with people you want to remember. I like the idea of a doll quilt swap that someone mentioned. Achievable in size and easy to post. Good luck.
10-22-2011, 08:31 PM
#65
Junior Member
Join Date: Mar 2011
Location: Pgh,Pa
Posts: 171
I have joined a fat quarter swap. I do not have a LQS (to my knowledge) near me, After reading all 5 pages of this thread, I am beginnig to thank I should pull out because the fat Q I get will be consider cheap. Would Joann's fat Q be Ok and not consider cheap?
10-22-2011, 08:58 PM
#66
Super Member
Join Date: Jul 2011
Location: Texas
Posts: 5,072
Originally Posted by trrmite
I have joined a fat quarter swap. I do not have a LQS (to my knowledge) near me, After reading all 5 pages of this thread, I am beginnig to thank I should pull out because the fat Q I get will be consider cheap. Would Joann's fat Q be Ok and not consider cheap?
10-22-2011, 10:42 PM
#67
Super Member
Join Date: Sep 2009
Location: Victoria, Australia
Posts: 3,724
I have participated in two swaps. One being the One Block/Month Swap where I corresponded with some lovely ladies from the U.S. and other countries and was very happy with the commitment and quality of the blocks I received.
The other was a Signature block swap with 174 participants and I was very happy with the organisation and result.
In both cases the quality of fabric and level of experience varied but you are aware of this before joining as these swaps were open to "all levels" so it is your decision whether go ahead and become involved.
I do think people need to read the WHOLE THREAD AND INSTRUCTIONS before committing themselves so they are confident that they can fulfil the criteria for the swap.
Having made the decision to join, jump in with a good attitude and enjoy making some new friends and have fun.
The other was a Signature block swap with 174 participants and I was very happy with the organisation and result.
In both cases the quality of fabric and level of experience varied but you are aware of this before joining as these swaps were open to "all levels" so it is your decision whether go ahead and become involved.
I do think people need to read the WHOLE THREAD AND INSTRUCTIONS before committing themselves so they are confident that they can fulfil the criteria for the swap.
Having made the decision to join, jump in with a good attitude and enjoy making some new friends and have fun.
10-22-2011, 11:03 PM
#68
Senior Member
Join Date: Mar 2010
Location: Buffalo, N.Y.
Posts: 383
I have only been in one siggie swap, original deadline was June - thought I'd have a fun summer project - deadline kept being extended so I finally received blocks 3 days before I had to return to school. I love the blocks I received but they are all still in the baggie.
I have seen a few other swaps I wanted to join but machine embroidered blocks were accepted and I wouldn't want any of those.
Swaps are fun but read rules and be open to change.
I have seen a few other swaps I wanted to join but machine embroidered blocks were accepted and I wouldn't want any of those.
Swaps are fun but read rules and be open to change.
10-23-2011, 04:51 AM
#69
Senior Member
Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: Willmar MN
Posts: 777
Originally Posted by trrmite
I have joined a fat quarter swap. I do not have a LQS (to my knowledge) near me, After reading all 5 pages of this thread, I am beginnig to thank I should pull out because the fat Q I get will be consider cheap. Would Joann's fat Q be Ok and not consider cheap?
10-23-2011, 05:04 AM
#70
Power Poster
Join Date: Jul 2010
Location: SoCal
Posts: 11,902
I think I would feel this way too after reading the tread but unless the swap states it needs to be a certain manufacture I would not worry about it being from Walmart or Joann's. I think what people are most concerned about is that it is 100% cotton and not thin cheese cloth and will fall apart. So just besure to finger what you are buying, no matter where you are buying it. Ofcourse if it says LQS in the swap rules you might want to contact the host and see what he/she thinks.
Originally Posted by trrmite
I have joined a fat quarter swap. I do not have a LQS (to my knowledge) near me, After reading all 5 pages of this thread, I am beginnig to thank I should pull out because the fat Q I get will be consider cheap. Would Joann's fat Q be Ok and not consider cheap?
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
deedum
Main
29
11-22-2014 06:08 AM
barnbum
General Chit-Chat (non-quilting talk)
20
08-25-2010 07:02 PM
