Quiltingboard Forums

Quiltingboard Forums (https://www.quiltingboard.com/)
-   Main (https://www.quiltingboard.com/main-f1/)
-   -   Beware of copyrights (https://www.quiltingboard.com/main-f1/beware-copyrights-t267382.html)

MaryTG 07-10-2015 11:17 AM

Used books (and DVDs etc) originals can be resold as the publisher's rights in that particular book or DVD expires at first sale. Copyright (not copywrite) is a bit trickier as patterns and designs cannot be copyrighted for useful items such as clothing and bedding. Separable elements can be copyrighted (such as a fancy cast figure on a belt buckle) as can original art. The big question is what constitutes art. Attribution has nothing to do with copyright and in fact can be a violation of trademark in and of itself (think of the brouhaha Alice Starmore raised with using her name to resell her yarns. In the US, quantity made has nothing to do with whether an item is violating copyright or not (highly unlikely). Fair use has nothing to do with attribution. The final object is not what is covered by copyright, but the written words are. Templates are specifically not covered. As Stanford University's Law site says:

In its most general sense, a fair use is any copying of copyrighted material done for a limited and “transformative” purpose, such as to comment upon, criticize, or parody a copyrighted work. Such uses can be done without permission from the copyright owner.

Terry in the ADK 07-10-2015 11:28 AM


Originally Posted by MaryTG (Post 7252984)
Used books (and DVDs etc) originals can be resold as the publisher's rights in that particular book or DVD expires at first sale. Copyright (not copywrite) is a bit trickier as patterns and designs cannot be copyrighted for useful items such as clothing and bedding. Separable elements can be copyrighted (such as a fancy cast figure on a belt buckle) as can original art. The big question is what constitutes art. Attribution has nothing to do with copyright and in fact can be a violation of trademark in and of itself (think of the brouhaha Alice Starmore raised with using her name to resell her yarns. In the US, quantity made has nothing to do with whether an item is violating copyright or not (highly unlikely). Fair use has nothing to do with attribution. The final object is not what is covered by copyright, but the written words are. Templates are specifically not covered. As Stanford University's Law site says:

In its most general sense, a fair use is any copying of copyrighted material done for a limited and “transformative” purpose, such as to comment upon, criticize, or parody a copyrighted work. Such uses can be done without permission from the copyright owner.

Hopefully you are an attorney! Sounds like you know the laws...sooo Can I or can't I make and sell more? completed quilts

what about wall hangings?

sewbizgirl 07-10-2015 11:29 AM

The Tabberone article is only addressing pattern TEMPLATES, like the shaped pattern pieces in your Butterick or Simplicity clothing pattern envelopes. It's different law for artwork, like an embroidery design, or for written text, like a written knitting pattern.

I'm not saying this is you, but this Tabberone article is the one always quoted by people who are looking to circumvent actual copyright law. If Tabberone said it's okay, they can take it. But it's apples and oranges, folks.

I guess the only sure way to know you are violating copyright law is when the lawsuit papers arrive in your mailbox, (or if you are lucky, a 'cease and desist' order, first.) Better safe than sorry.


Originally Posted by Buckeye Rose (Post 7251851)
The copyright pertains only to the written instructions that you purchased. You may not copy and sell/give those instructions. The pattern designer may not tell you how many quilts you can make or what you do with them once completed. There have been many discussions on this board and I suggest you search for a discussion about "Tabberone"....I think that is the subject. There is lots of information out there that is false, mostly coming from people who don't understand the copyright laws.


sewbizgirl 07-10-2015 11:33 AM

To make matters worse, you aren't supposed to use half the fabrics made nowadays for any commercial use either! Definitely no licensed character prints, unless you buy a "license" from the parent company (Disney or whoever...).

Jingle 07-10-2015 12:12 PM

I know is there has been lots of talk on here about copyright laws. Even Patricej had posted about it.
I don't worry about all this as I never sell quilts. I give them away.

MaryTG 07-10-2015 12:16 PM


Originally Posted by Terry in the ADK (Post 7252997)
Hopefully you are an attorney! Sounds like you know the laws...sooo Can I or can't I make and sell more? completed quilts

what about wall hangings?

I am not an attorney, just someone who regular participates in copyright discussions on Ravelry in the Copyright Matters group. We try to find the actual laws in various countries rather than what some people interpret them to be in their favor. The US Copyright Office released a new Compendium late last year that clears up a lot of the misinformation that some knitting designers had convinced many people was actually what the law said rather than what they wished it said. You can dig into it here: http://copyright.gov/comp3/docs/compendium.pdf

As for your specific case, I would guess (an this is a purely amatuer guess, not legal advise) that the embroidery design would be viewed as art and not a useful item and would therefor be covered by copyright law.

Skylark53 07-10-2015 12:29 PM

Along this line...I see along a lot of fabric selvedges "for non-commercial home use only." I potentially wanted to make a few things using this fabric to sell on Etsy or the like. I take it this means I can't? I wouldn't exactly call what my use would be "commercial." That seems awfully limiting. I'm noticing this appearing more and more often on selvedges :(

Onebyone 07-10-2015 05:39 PM

"for non-commercial home use only." I ignore this. I'm not mass producing for commercial sales.

MarleneC 07-10-2015 06:45 PM

I question this also as it states the designs are copyrighted but that isn't the same as giving someone else the designs to use. I have a friend who also got caught in a mess like this when she had made a lap robe for a relative in a nursing home and others wanted one and she was told by the husband of the designer that she couldn't sell anything made with those patterns. I questioned that answer also.

MarleneC 07-10-2015 06:50 PM


Originally Posted by ghostrider (Post 7252086)
Right or wrong, consider the facts of this case.
This is a well-known company with probably more than enough money to take you to court.
You asked and were formally denined permission to make and sell multiple copies of the design so they now know your name and probably the sales venue as well.
The question you have to answer is this: are you willing to risk a court battle to prove the company is over reaching its authority?

She isn't going to make and sell multiple copies of the design--the ones she bought--she is only wanting to sell items she makes using those designs.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 07:40 PM.