Quiltingboard Forums

Quiltingboard Forums (https://www.quiltingboard.com/)
-   Main (https://www.quiltingboard.com/main-f1/)
-   -   Could someone explain something to me, please? (https://www.quiltingboard.com/main-f1/could-someone-explain-something-me-please-t189762.html)

ghostrider 05-24-2012 07:22 AM

My XH is a master carpenter and used to go bananas when I talked about having to add "extra" to the measurements for seam allowances. Overlapping joins seldom happen in his world.

QuiltMania 05-24-2012 07:25 AM


Originally Posted by callie8799 (Post 5237501)
First, thank you for the responses... I'm coming to the conclusion this is something I just need "to do" and not think about. if I need a certain size finished square, I just need to cut the fabric 1/2 inch larger than I need for I am taking a 1/2 inch off the width and length. If I need 1/2 square triangles, I need to add 7/8"... (going to make a cheat sheet at home)...

but I just can't get my head around the reasoning (tell ya, I'm not good at math reasoning) if I taking a 1/4 inch off each side (1/2 " total for width and 1/2" total for length) that still gives me 1" taken off for seam allowances. why isn't that calculated- for 1/2 off width + 1/2 off length = 1").

ugh. guess there are some things I will never understand and that's why we have cheat sheets.... but now I know why my current quilt has gotten wonky...

thank you! :

It ends up being 1/2 inch because the amount being taken off is in different directions. Think of a capital L. The long arm of the L is in the vertical direction. No matter how much you take off in the vertical direction, it will not affect the short arm of the L which is in the horizontal direction.The same is true for the short arm of the L. No matter how much you take off in the horizontal direction, it will never affect the vertical direction because they are in different directions.

gigi712 05-24-2012 07:31 AM

This is waaaay over my head. I'm going to start another thread and explain the problem I'm having that have to do with this exact thing.

Friday1961 05-24-2012 07:37 AM


Originally Posted by ghostrider (Post 5239392)
Come at it from the other way. Your 4" cut square is 4" wide by 4" high...or 8" total if you combine them. If you then subtract the 1" of seam allowances, you get 7". Divide that in half (because it's a square and length and width are the same) and you get a 3½" square. Does that help you see it?

If you consider both directions (length and width) for one element (the seam allowances), you have to do it for the other as well (the square sides).

Obviously from a true mathematician! This explanation makes the most sense of all.

Sometimes math--an exact science--just does not seem to make sense.....but it always does! (and this opinion is from a severely math challenged English major!)

Material Witness 05-24-2012 11:15 AM

I am not good at math, either, but luckily, I think in pictures. You are only measuring straight across one direction, so you only have to use the 1/4 inch on the east and west sides. Later you can do north and south, but that is a separte function.

bearisgray, it looks like you should be an engineer.

captlynhall 05-24-2012 12:13 PM

I am so happy to see I'm not the only one whose eyes glaze over when it comes to figuring the math of quilt pieces. However, I did 'get it' from the many simple explanations in the thread. Thanks to you all for that. Now I have to think on the 7/8" thing. LOL

RkayD 05-24-2012 01:02 PM

Math has never been my friend. I lost all hope when the alphabet showed up to join the party. I never got it to make sense..it didn't matter that the letter was a sub for a number..it was all alphabet soup after that. =)

bearisgray 05-24-2012 02:40 PM

1 Attachment(s)
The basic concept - for a four-sided figure with 90 degree corners to figure 'finished size' - assuming 1/4 inch seams:

(Unfinished) Starting width minus 1/2 inch = finished width

(Unfinished) Starting length minus 1/2 inch = finished length

The attached drawing might help

callie8799 05-24-2012 05:21 PM

Ahhhhh, the lightbulb is glowing now- it does get dim, but I just reread the posts and it gets brighter...
Madquilter, thank you for the the verbal image of sewing the rectangles to the top then to a side- coupled with explanations and even concrete drawings, provided by other members, I am able to grasp why we only lose 1/2" compared to the 1" I thought we should lose.

I can not thank each one of you, for I didn't write down all the names who posted, for your contributions and helpfullness- I greatly appreciate it. I appreciate the diagrams, the logical/mathematical explanations, the nods of agreements of those who feel the same why as I do (it sure feels good that I'm not the only one in the boat). Now, I know why I open this message board first....

wishing y'all peace,
Deb

MimiBug123 05-24-2012 11:32 PM

Just don't over-analyze. Just think of your 4" square minus 1/4" on the top= 3 3/4 minus another 1/4" on the bottom - 3 1/2. You now have a rectangle 3 1/2 by 4. OK, you still have to sew the sides. 1/4" off the left side and your rectangle is now 3 3/4 horizontally by 3 1/2 vertically. Sew another 1/4 seam on the right side and your rectangle is now a 3 1/2" square.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 05:37 AM.