It looks great to me also. But if it's bugging you, I think Rodney has an answer. His drawing is very good in describing what he thinks it needs. I think QuiltnNan is right about the bottom shadowing. It would be more realistic. And I think what you drew would make the right side correct. So you have it fixed, right? I think so. Don't we have great quilters here to help us when we need it? I want to thank you all for helping Buckeye Rose. Next time it might be me.

I would let it alone. My mother used to say, "You are going to fix it until you ruin the whole thing," which frequently turned out to be the case. It is a beautiful design, well executed as it is. froggyintexas