Guess I'll be the odd one out...I actually like the toothy one. Think it adds to the whimsy.

I vote smile. Although I like the 2nd one too. :)

I like the first one and the third one the best. :) They are all super adorable though!

I like them both very much. I would go with the last one.

I like the second one but I think that if you were to make the mouth an "0" instead of a dot it would work. Especially if it is a pin cushion.

vote for the last pic...isn't he cute...

I like your original best--it's more octopus-looking--but all three are winners.

I vote for the last one also! It is really cute! Great job!

Too cute I like the last one but you could embroider the teeth in cream or white floss.

The little feller is cute whatever you decide, but I like the "toothy" grin best!