I like the first version best. This will be a really kool quilt. BrendaK

I like the square version. I also agree with a couple other people about adding sashing. The color of your table looks great against the green blocks. Perhaps you might use that color for the sashing.

~ Cindy

I like the first picture better too. have you tried adding a solid green sashing or alternating block ?

I like the more traditional square set up... You could always quilt with pink? :) Great quilt ! ! ! it will keep her in your Hugs and Heart felt Love no matter what...! !

I like the square better.

I really like the off-set version. Much more interesting. And I sure hope you don't go and put any pink in there. It's lovely like it is.

I can see them with an attic window setting, does not have to be large 'window frames'.

I love both versions. great job.

I prefer the offset version. It's more interesting and keeps the eyes moving. If you decide to sash it, I like the color of your table. Pink would be too jarring and take away from the earthy nature of the quilt.

I like the square but then depending on the binding you put on it;it could go either way .. No help I know !!LOL :-)