Quiltingboard Forums

Quiltingboard Forums (https://www.quiltingboard.com/)
-   Main (https://www.quiltingboard.com/main-f1/)
-   -   Licensing (https://www.quiltingboard.com/main-f1/licensing-t154579.html)

Somerset Val 09-22-2011 09:25 AM

Thank you, MTS - this is really helpful!

ploverwi2 09-22-2011 09:32 AM

They can be used for personal use, gifts, etc. However nothing made with licensed fabrics can be sold for a profit, not at craft shows or elsewhere. You would have to get permission from the owner (team, etc) of the license in order to produce something with the fabric and sell it somewhere, no if's, ands, or buts about it. Many times, when you purchas a pattern also, it will say that you can not use that pattern to make something to sell. Other patterns will actually say that it is ok to sell what you make by using that pattern. When we find a picture in a magazine, etc. and want to make a pictoral quilt from it, we are always supposed to contact the artist for permission, because otherwise it is considered a copyright violation.

Sadiemae 09-22-2011 09:35 AM


Originally Posted by BonniFeltz

Originally Posted by jaciqltznok

Originally Posted by MIJul
What about the embroidery patterns? I see people selling Disney characters all the time on bibs, shirts, etc. at craft shows. Do they get permission from Disney when they purchase the patterns? Just wondering...

usually not and just because they do it does not mean it is right/legal!

Question on Disney and stuff. I am buying a Brother embroidery machine which has preloaded Disney images on it. I plan on possibly using these for quilts and items to give away as presents, not to make money. IF I wanted to put some things with it on for a booth at a quilt show (small local lets say) to sell for some extra money it would be ok if I have disclaimer that I do not represent Disney, yadda yadda?

If you read the information that comes with your machine, I am pretty sure it will say you cannot sell items with the embroidery on them.

madamekelly 09-22-2011 09:35 AM


Originally Posted by QuiltnNan
Thanks MTS. that is great info. i have bookmarked it.

me too. thank you.

threadsdmr 09-22-2011 09:37 AM

I have a friend using licensed fabric and selling them all over the place and she is doing a craft fair this weekend. Does this mean she is breaking the law?

OKLAHOMA PEACH 09-22-2011 09:37 AM

The check makers now have limited teams, OU went franchise, only one bank has bought the use, no one has transferred their accounts so they can get the OU checks. How did that work out for you OU and I can't even remember what bank carries them.

Somerset Val 09-22-2011 09:52 AM


Originally Posted by ploverwi2
They can be used for personal use, gifts, etc. However nothing made with licensed fabrics can be sold for a profit, not at craft shows or elsewhere. You would have to get permission from the owner (team, etc) of the license in order to produce something with the fabric and sell it somewhere, no if's, ands, or buts about it. Many times, when you purchas a pattern also, it will say that you can not use that pattern to make something to sell. Other patterns will actually say that it is ok to sell what you make by using that pattern. When we find a picture in a magazine, etc. and want to make a pictoral quilt from it, we are always supposed to contact the artist for permission, because otherwise it is considered a copyright violation.

If you read what MTS has posted and go on to the relevant site to read the info there, it seems that this isn't so as long as you include a disclamour in your labelling!

Pat G 09-22-2011 10:00 AM


Originally Posted by MTS

Originally Posted by MZStitch
It's unlawful to sell a product that displays someone else's image without the image owner's permission -- even if the maker of the product lawfully purchased the fabric (or any other material) that contains the image. The fabric comes with a "personal use license".

The rationale is: consumers would likely falsely believe that the image owner either made the product or sponsors, endorses, or is somehow associated with the maker of the product made from the fabric (in violation of trademark law).

Sorry!

Not quite.
http://www.tabberone.com/Trademarks/...edFabric.shtml

Wow, very powerful reading. I read the whole thing over & over so it would make sense to me. I even printed it to share with friends.

joyceinoh 09-22-2011 10:08 AM

Golly, I had never even thought of that.

I have bought fabric with College LOGOS on, from ebay.

What about buying /selling shirts a\etc with logos on them at gr. sales.? You see it all the time.

Sadiemae 09-22-2011 10:10 AM


Originally Posted by joyceinoh
Golly, I had never even thought of that.

I have bought fabric with College LOGOS on, from ebay.

What about buying /selling shirts a\etc with logos on them at gr. sales.? You see it all the time.

I always wondered about quilts, shirts, etc... when purchased at auctions and thrift stores. I don't see how they could ever enforce the laws that exist today. People have no idea when they sell or purchase items like this what the laws are.

FroggyinTexas 09-22-2011 10:15 AM


Originally Posted by MTS

Originally Posted by MZStitch
It's unlawful to sell a product that displays someone else's image without the image owner's permission -- even if the maker of the product lawfully purchased the fabric (or any other material) that contains the image. The fabric comes with a "personal use license".

The rationale is: consumers would likely falsely believe that the image owner either made the product or sponsors, endorses, or is somehow associated with the maker of the product made from the fabric (in violation of trademark law).

Sorry!

Not quite.
http://www.tabberone.com/Trademarks/...edFabric.shtml

Great work! Thanks for the explanation and the legal references. froggyintexas

ploverwi2 09-22-2011 10:20 AM

Wow! Was I ever incorrect with my words. I appreciate that you posted this for all of us. I have a whole different understanding about using licensed fabrics. My understanding was wrong all the time, thanks so much again.

FroggyinTexas 09-22-2011 11:07 AM


Originally Posted by MZStitch
It's unlawful to sell a product that displays someone else's image without the image owner's permission -- even if the maker of the product lawfully purchased the fabric (or any other material) that contains the image. The fabric comes with a "personal use license".

The rationale is: consumers would likely falsely believe that the image owner either made the product or sponsors, endorses, or is somehow associated with the maker of the product made from the fabric (in violation of trademark law).

Sorry!

Designers could effectively shut down interstate commerce if this interpretation of the law is correct. For example, if I use a Smucker's jar that once had jelly in it and which clearly has Smucker's etched into the glass to make a pin cushion to send to a friend in Oklahoma as a contribution to a charity auction, I would be breaking the law?

Or, if I decide to start driving to Dallas in my Ford Freestyle and people pay me $10 each for the ride (assuming I have met all the insurance, et.al. requirements), could Ford limit my use of the automobile I paid $23,000 for by writing on the inside of the hood, "for personal use only?"

Give me a break! The people who designed the fabric get their cut when they sell the design to whomever, and manufactuers get their cut when they sell to wholesalers who get their cut when they sell the fabric to a retailer and the retailers get their cut when they sell it to a consumer who then should be free to use that product for any purpose not specifically forbidden by law. Run it up a flagpole, cover the baby's rump with it, or make a quilt for sale for profit--if I give the item I made away and the prson to whom I give it decides to sell it, does the person who created the design still have an ecoomic interest? This whole thing is absurd.

I don't know of any law that gives a person or business a perpetual right to say what an individual can do with legally acquired property. froggyintexas

OKLAHOMA PEACH 09-22-2011 12:06 PM

Yes there should be a rule of how long and exactly when it becomes public property. Once it is bought retail, it should be public property.

suesembroidery 09-22-2011 04:27 PM

When I purchased my first Brother's embroidery machine, the sales lady told me I could sell the shirt with the design on it. I was really selling the shirt not the design. I went along with that until a few years ago. My daughter sells my embroidery items as a vendor in the state of Washington. At a sale she was told to remove all licensed items because a complaint was made. They said we could give them away, but not sell them. We complied and gave a few away if they bought more than two items, they got one free from us. I looked at all my material that came with the machine and could not find any information. Went to a dealer in the area and they told us it was true. You can give away, personal use, but, not sell. I was really upset over it, but loved the machine. I went in asked the lady that sold the machine to me and she still was using that line in her sales. Another sales lady told me they were correct in Washington. They can come get your machine and anything that you use to produce what you are selling. It seems unfair if they put the designs in the machine and sell cards to use in the machine and charge the price they do and we can not help to earn the money so we can buy more. From that day forward, if it is licensed in any way, I do not buy.

QuiltnLady1 09-22-2011 05:23 PM

When Laurel Burch passed away, her heirs began to aggressively go after folks who were selling things made with her fabric. When you get attacked by lawyers, most folks cave in. When someone took the heirs to court, they buckled.

Patterns are another area of murky copyright. Some makers claim you cannot sell or enter in a show anything made from a pattern you legally purchased -- that is also not true. You can't sell the pattern, but what you make from it simply needs to give credit to the designer,

Here is a link that should help understand that as well:
http://www.tabberone.com/Trademarks/...Patterns.shtml

karate lady 09-22-2011 05:35 PM


Originally Posted by MZStitch
It's unlawful to sell a product that displays someone else's image without the image owner's permission -- even if the maker of the product lawfully purchased the fabric (or any other material) that contains the image. The fabric comes with a "personal use license".

The rationale is: consumers would likely falsely believe that the image owner either made the product or sponsors, endorses, or is somehow associated with the maker of the product made from the fabric (in violation of trademark law).

Sorry!

I have been told both ways. one was you cannot sell it, and two that you bought it and can sell it. I solve it by letting the person who wants the item to get the material and I just charge for making it.

Sadiemae 09-22-2011 05:51 PM


Originally Posted by suesembroidery
When I purchased my first Brother's embroidery machine, the sales lady told me I could sell the shirt with the design on it. I was really selling the shirt not the design. I went along with that until a few years ago. My daughter sells my embroidery items as a vendor in the state of Washington. At a sale she was told to remove all licensed items because a complaint was made. They said we could give them away, but not sell them. We complied and gave a few away if they bought more than two items, they got one free from us. I looked at all my material that came with the machine and could not find any information. Went to a dealer in the area and they told us it was true. You can give away, personal use, but, not sell. I was really upset over it, but loved the machine. I went in asked the lady that sold the machine to me and she still was using that line in her sales. Another sales lady told me they were correct in Washington. They can come get your machine and anything that you use to produce what you are selling. It seems unfair if they put the designs in the machine and sell cards to use in the machine and charge the price they do and we can not help to earn the money so we can buy more. From that day forward, if it is licensed in any way, I do not buy.

My machine came with information stating that you could not sell any items with the Disney Characters on it. If I remember correctly it was stated on the color photo pages that showed the designs available on the machine.

busygranny 09-22-2011 06:12 PM

In regard to Disney embroidery patterns. I was in the market for a new machine, checked out Brother. Clerk informed me all these Disney patterns came on the machine. I'm thinking "WOW" those would be great sellers, as I make to sell. Pretty soon she informs me I can't use them on articles to sell. They were for my personal use. Well my grand children are all past the Disney stage and what use would I have for them? Needless to say, she lost a sale. I sure did not want a machine loaded with Disney patterns that I had no use for. So I bought a Husqvarna. I've also seen purse patterns that say you can't sell any made from the pattern. Needless to say I don't buy anything that says you can't make and sell. Let them sit with their patterns. They'll loosen up, sooner or later.

arizonagirl 09-23-2011 08:55 AM


Originally Posted by MTS

Originally Posted by MZStitch
It's unlawful to sell a product that displays someone else's image without the image owner's permission -- even if the maker of the product lawfully purchased the fabric (or any other material) that contains the image. The fabric comes with a "personal use license".

The rationale is: consumers would likely falsely believe that the image owner either made the product or sponsors, endorses, or is somehow associated with the maker of the product made from the fabric (in violation of trademark law).

Sorry!

Not quite.
http://www.tabberone.com/Trademarks/...edFabric.shtml

I was going to post this same link. It is very interesting to read.

Queen 09-23-2011 09:33 AM

I was asked if I would sell a purse that I made. I told them that legally I could not, but I would take a donation.
They ended up giving me more than I would have charged if I could have sold it.

Mary

tabberone 09-24-2011 06:36 AM


Originally Posted by jaciqltznok

Originally Posted by MTS

sadly this is no longer TRUE either. IT can also lead to some harsh complications later on.

The first use doctorine means you get to use ONE TIME. Not that you can mass produce items with that fabric or pattern.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
We try to keep current on case law, if this is no longer true do you have any links to court cases that reverse that information?


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 12:59 PM.