I slightly prefer the overall square one for this particular quilt, but if I were receiving it as a mom with a baby, I would want it crib size to grow with baby and to cover up mommy and baby when snuggling in a rocker. But either way they look good, honestly.

I prefer the first one. I just the over all scale of the components better.

I like the rectangles. But it's lovely, regardless!

I'm for even. I like the symmetry, and if they decide to use it as a wallhanging (they might, many would!) square will work better.

But both look lovely, so go with your gut...

Alison

Nicely done

As usual, the replies to these questions are all over. I prefer the rectangle, too. I think it can be used longer.

Ditto. I would go square.

I like the even borders best. Beautiful quilt!

Beautiful quilts. I prefer the square one.

I've made quilts with uneven sides but if given the choice I vote for the even quilt this time, but it's your quilt and you have the last say! how's that for being political correct!