I like the first one best, second choice would be #4

I like the first one too!

I also would vote for the first one. Beautiful fabrics

I did mine in Greens and if I could send a photo I would. Needs light contrast so I would go with #1

All are pretty, but I like No. 1. It doesn't detract from the blocks and it supports and balances the colors you have in them.....in my opinion. This is going to be a very pretty quilt!

That's going to be soooo pretty! I am voting for #1.

I vote for the last one or option 4. Thanks for asking.
Karen

I surprised myself, i like number 1.

I'm no help. I cannot see anything 'wrong' with any of them. They do give different appearances. So, it depends upon what you are after. I made this pattern twice and had very different (but pleasing) results. Don't forget to show us what you finally chose. At this point votes for the first one seem to dominate.

Absolutely #1, your first choice. Save the other fabrics for other quilts. :)