Quiltingboard Forums

Quiltingboard Forums (https://www.quiltingboard.com/)
-   Main (https://www.quiltingboard.com/main-f1/)
-   -   Rotary Cutters- ARE they all created Equal?? (https://www.quiltingboard.com/main-f1/rotary-cutters-they-all-created-equal-t115498.html)

stormatsea45 04-13-2011 07:38 AM

I have and really like olfa cutters. Recently bought the new Ginger (sp?)with a 50% coupon at JoAnn's and it's like cutting through butter!!!! Really nice.

grammysharon 04-13-2011 08:06 AM

The cutting blades need to be changed often. From what you say I think you need a new blade not a new cutter. :D

feffertim 04-13-2011 08:14 AM

I really love my martelli also, I have several cutters but I usually end up using the Martelli. It feels so good in my hand.

matraina 04-13-2011 09:12 AM

I have the Olfas, too. I have the kind you squeeze and the blade comes out. It feels "rubbery" and it feels good in my hand.

chuckbere15 04-13-2011 09:24 AM

Harbor fright sells 45mm blade for about 1.99 and they work well. I don't think the are the best, but at that price, you can afford to change your blade more often. When the rotary cutters start to leave string, it is time to change the blade. I notice this a lot when cutting multiple layers. However, when I cut a single layer, I don't get the string affect with a duller blade.

lauriequilts 04-13-2011 10:10 AM

I have a gingher and just love it! I also have 45mm and 60mm Olfa and they work fine too. I only buy the blades at Joann's when they are 50% off.

grandma anna 04-13-2011 10:16 AM

Blades have to be changed pretty often.

Bluelady 04-13-2011 10:19 AM

I prefer my Martelli's. The bend in the handle makes it so much easier on my wrist and shoulder.

Central Ohio Quilter 04-13-2011 10:55 AM

I have several different brands, but my favorite is my Gingher. I got it at JoAnn's for 60% off at a Black Friday Sale.

justlooking 04-13-2011 11:23 AM

Olfa rotary cutters.

Anne P 04-13-2011 11:53 AM

I have a couple of Olfa's and a Fons and Porter. I really like the F & P better. The blade retracts automatically, which is sooo handy. It's not ergonomic, but it works well.

hawaiilove 04-13-2011 12:00 PM


Originally Posted by #1piecemaker
I need a new rotary cutter. I've been using one I purchased at Walmart and it just doesn't cut very good. I'm constantly having to go back and cut threads. Which one do you like best and why?

I waited till I got a sale price on the Gingher rotary cutter - well balanced and not too heavy - it cuts great !!

quiltingnana1 04-13-2011 12:02 PM

Love my Olfas. Try changing the blade.

deedee 04-13-2011 12:08 PM

I agree - Olfa is the best

bettysew 04-13-2011 12:17 PM


Originally Posted by BKrenning

Originally Posted by TonnieLoree

Originally Posted by BKrenning
I have Olfa's--all sizes that close automatically when you release the handle except for the tiny one--it is manual; a few dollar bin cheapos that I use for fleece & paper and a Martelli 45mm. I love, love, love the Martelli for long cutting sessions but you have to remember to close the blade shield every time you set it down. Also, it only likes the blades without notches or it will wobble. There is a right & left hand version so make sure you get the correct one for you.

So, no, they are not made equal. You have to find one that is comfortable for you at a price you're willing to pay. For a good all around--easy & cheap to find blades for--I would recommend Olfa. For problems with carpal tunnel or hand strength--I recommend Martelli. For pretty--I recommend Donna Dewberry!

Seriously, a right and left handed version? I bet the left handed one is more expensive. What is the difference? That just seems like another price gouge for those that do not know how to adapt. I'm left handed, btw, and I do just fine with all of my rotary cutters.

Yes, a right & left handed version. You hold it differently than any other rotary cutter. It has a handle that sticks out of the side. It's kind of like driving a bicycle. It's hard to explain but it really is easier to use and doesn't zap my wrist like my Olfa ones do if I cut for a long time. Oh, and the lefty version is the same price as the righty but mine is racing red. You get black.

http://www.martellicatalog.com/mm5/m...tegory_Code=RC

I have this same left handed cutter. One great advantage for me is that since I have RA, standing for a long period of time is painful and I am able to do almost all of my cutting sitting down with the same accuracy as standing.

OzarksGma 04-13-2011 01:52 PM

I have the new Tru Cut electric rotary blade sharpener.
It works fine. Except it doesn't take out the nicks.
It does extend the life of the blade as long as the blade just needs a touch of sharpening.

To the post that said after sharpening the blade there were still threads that had to be clipped. That means there is a nick in the blade and no sharpening will take it out.....
Toss the blade.[/quote]

It does not always mean a nick in the blade, maybe it is a bad mat. Sometimes when your mat gets used so much it does not heal it will leave a negligible groove and when you cut across it it will leave uncut threads.
I have used a Martelli cutter for the last 8 years and wouldn't trade it for anything else. When I put a new blade in I can cut 20 layers easily. I have to step down to about 12-14 layers when the blade gets used a lot.
These cutters are true ergonomic cutters and for anyone with arthritis, carpel tunnel, or hand fatigue they can't be beat. They even take the strain off a bad shoulder because you don't have to put your elbow out to the side and cut at 45 degrees.
You cut with the normal swing of your arm at 90 degrees straight out from your body. Since you have better control of the cutter straight out, there is less chance of veering off the side when cutting. The 45 degree cutters cost about $25.00 which is less than the new quick change Olfa cutters which run $30.00. I a real fan. I have both the 45mm and the 60mm cutters.
OzarksGma

e4 04-13-2011 01:55 PM

I personally love my Martelli rotary cutter! The blades last a very long time - I cut a lot of fabric and have only had to change the blade once in almost 2 years.

OzarksGma 04-13-2011 01:57 PM

I have tried all the cutters - Fiskars, Olfa, etc. - and believe it or not I prefer the Dritz. It seems to fit in my hand the best.

I also tried one of those yellow orbital sharpeners and found it quite lacking. I did hear that there are folks you can mail your used blades to that will sharpen them and mail them back. Anyone got an address or website?[/quote]

I sharpen the rotary cutters, both 45 and 60mm. I own a shop and sharpen the rotary blades and scissors. You can mail them in and I will sharpen and mail them back to you.
OzarksGma

Numa 04-13-2011 01:58 PM

Love my Gingher !

OzarksGma 04-13-2011 02:02 PM

I see in the paper that JoAnns has all rotary cutters and supplies at 50% off[/quote]

The only problem with JoAnns, they don't carry the Martelli. Top quality and they are worth every penny even paying full price. If you've ever used one, there is no going back to the old cutters no matter what brand you used.
OzarksGma

OzarksGma 04-13-2011 02:11 PM

I've tried all the rest and have settled for the best...Gingher, they are the best. They make excellent scissors as well. A pricey rotary cutter, but there is no comparison to anything else. They are expensive, but worth every penny.
Blessings,
MaryAnna[/quote]

Haven't tried the Gingher rotary cutters, I use Martelli.
Gingher used to be an excellent source for scissors, but since they moved their production facilities from Italy to Mexico they are not worth carrying out of the place you purchased them. They do not hold an edge so they do not stay sharp very long, they have to be sharpened more frequently which shortens their life tremendously.
OzarksGma

debcavan 04-13-2011 02:17 PM

I like one with a curved handle. I have a blade sharpener that you can leave the blade in to sharpen it. I love it.

Central Ohio Quilter 04-13-2011 02:25 PM

Has anyone tried the rotary cutters from Connecting Threads? They have 2 styles from True Cut, a straight one and a "bent" one.

They also have another bent one called Ergo rotary cutter.

I see that Connecting threads is also coming out with a electric rotary blade sharpener for $65, on sale now for $52. For that price, it had better be pretty darn good!

carolynjo 04-13-2011 02:26 PM

Try putting a tiny drop of oil on your cutter blade. Sometimes that helps the blade to work better.

emerald46 04-13-2011 03:22 PM

I have all sizes of the Olfa. They are all I've ever used.

mjsylvstr 04-13-2011 04:31 PM

using OLFA right now but when I need to purchase new, I was thinking of the new CUTTING EDGE RULERS and CUTTERS.

The ruler's edge has something built in to help keep the blades of the cutter sharp.

BUT,,,until I need new, I will continue to use the Olfa......

quilter in the making 04-13-2011 05:12 PM

I will never use my blade sharpener again. I'm scared of it to begin with, so DH said he'd sharpen all my blades for me and before he knew it he had a deep cut on his thumb. It was bad enough for stitches, but like most men refused to get it checked. Kept splitting back open and bleeding for several days. Me sharpen after watching that? Nope! I'll just keep buying new blades.

MonkeeGirl 04-13-2011 05:21 PM

Martelli, Martelli, Martelli!! Mr. Webster hasn't got the word to describe how wonderful this rotary cutter is!

gypsylady5 04-13-2011 05:29 PM

There is a difference. Pick the cutter that fits your hand best and then buy Olfa blades. I do like the blade from Harbor Freight - they seem to last longer and are certainly cheaper. I wish they had them in 60 mm. It really is the blade that makes the difference. Don't skimp there!!!

granof5 04-13-2011 06:32 PM

Changing your blade in your rotary cutter is like changing your needle in your sewing machine. I don't mean to sound mean here, but it is called maintenance. Change your needle in your machine, oil your machine, and change your blades when they make you work. Happy Quilting!

almostfree 04-13-2011 06:36 PM


Originally Posted by miholmes
I love my Olfa cutter as well. However if you're going to purchase them I would tell you to wait until Joann's has their 40 or 50% sale. That way you can get the cutter and some replacement blades for a better price.

Joann's has a good sale on things right now....but not sure if rotary cutters are on sale. You could check on their website.

eb in calif 04-13-2011 09:43 PM

It isn't always the cutter that is a problem - could be the mat. I have a whole table cutting mat that is no where as good as the much smaller mats.

incoming2me 04-13-2011 10:04 PM


Originally Posted by OzarksGma
The only problem with JoAnns, they don't carry the Martelli. Top quality and they are worth every penny even paying full price. If you've ever used one, there is no going back to the old cutters no matter what brand you used.
OzarksGma

The brick and mortar stores may not carry the Martelli's but their website does! :)
AND they are on sale now!

http://www.joann.com/joann/search/se...questid=156086

katigirl 04-13-2011 11:28 PM

Have used and like fiskars for years. Tried olfas and didn't like them. Have never tried clover.

mshawii 04-14-2011 09:25 AM

I like the kind that when you press down the blade is engaged and when you let up the blade retracts. No problem getting cut with it or forgetting to retract the blade. Jan

QuilterSue 04-14-2011 09:41 AM

I'm sure it is not the cutter that is giving you fits. It is more likely the blade. Sometimes it is the cutting mat. If you use the same places all the time to cut, they could be worn out and not as forgiving as when the mat was new.

Jim's Gem 04-14-2011 04:18 PM

My Martelli cutter which I have used for about 6 or 7 years just broke!! I am bummed. But, I love that cutter. It is only a spring that broke, I will probably e-mail the company and tell them, but in the meantime, Connecting threads has it on sale for 20% off so I ordered a new one last night along with some platinum needles and some thread.

Jim's Gem 04-14-2011 04:21 PM

Oh, just saw post from incoming. that's a better price than I got! I looked at JoAnns on Monday but they do not carry them in my store, I assumed (falsely) that they just did not carry them. That's a great price for the 5 blade replacement pack!!!!

Jim's Gem 04-14-2011 04:24 PM


Originally Posted by Central Ohio Quilter
Has anyone tried the rotary cutters from Connecting Threads? They have 2 styles from True Cut, a straight one and a "bent" one.

They also have another bent one called Ergo rotary cutter.

I see that Connecting threads is also coming out with a electric rotary blade sharpener for $65, on sale now for $52. For that price, it had better be pretty darn good!

The Ergo one is the Martelli cutter. I just ordered myself another one last night!

Shorebird 04-14-2011 06:30 PM

Love my ergonomic Martelli cutter, with their blades. Blades are more costly, but stay sharper much longer, cleaner cuts, less stress on my hands and wrists.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 06:04 PM.