It seems everyone has their own opinion, including me at #1, so I think we only confused you more. You have good judgment so it will be fine whatever you do, people will like it. Relax and good luck.

My vote is for either #1 or #4. since everyone is so split, it seems like any choice would be a good one!

I agree with all of the above - for all of the reasons stated above! Each option would finish your project beautifully and influence the overall look in it's own way. I say select what appeals the most to you or maybe this is one of those that requires a little 'eenie, meenie, miney, moe.."

Can't wait to see the finish - it's bound to be fabulous!

Maybe it's time to number pieces of paper and pull one out of a hat? Seems as soon as I do this I immediately choose the one my mind wanted in the first place:=) I agree either will look wonderful.

You know you're going to get plenty of votes for each one. They're all so similar one has to really inspect for differences. I recommend you put all your photos in a line and flip back and forth, not dissecting but simply reacting and go with the layout that creates a spark for you. I found mine in #4.

No. 1 for me.

Watson