Quiltingboard Forums

Quiltingboard Forums (https://www.quiltingboard.com/)
-   Main (https://www.quiltingboard.com/main-f1/)
-   -   Update on Rowenta fire (https://www.quiltingboard.com/main-f1/update-rowenta-fire-t198247.html)

Kay in Iowa 08-21-2012 07:30 AM

Update on Rowenta fire
 
Well, after a very busy summer, I finally sent in my iron that caught on fire as I was using it. I sent with it, photos of my burnt hand as well as photos of the big burn hole in my backing fabric. I received a phone call from Rowenta about 10 days ago while we were at the Iowa State Fair. Their representative told me the iron was manufactured in 2007 - I probably didn't use it until 2009 I think - maybe 2010 - but they had the results from looking at the iron and he said the cord has "tiny wires in it that break from using the iron" - I said, "so it was a defective cord" - "Oh no - it was just used a lot and this happens quite often"................to say I was STUNDED was an understatement. He actually told me "this happens quite often"...........BEWARE - BEWARE. I told him I have been ironing for over 60 years and I certainly hope it NEVER HAPPENS AGAIN! I am still in a state of disbelief! Since I was outside the building that had the State Fire Marshal's display at the State Fair when he called me on my cell phone - I went in and talked to the State Building Code Inspector. He advised me to contact the Product Safety Council which I intend to do. We arrived home last night and here was a box with a new Rowenta iron in it. Now - here's the question - would you use it? And, if not, what iron would you buy? I have two other Rowentas and now I'm gun shy. I'm kind of anxious about the whole thing. Oh - one more thing - the quilt I made that caught on fire - I embroidered a patch for that section of the backing - and would you believe I WON A BLUE RIBBON ON THE QUILT at the Iowa State Fair................happy dance, happy dance! ! ! Will try and get a picture on soon.

QuiltingKrazy 08-21-2012 07:34 AM

Well great news about the quilt at least! As for the iron.... I guess I would use it with caution. Check the cord frequently for cracks! I am thinking the person you spoke to may have mis-spoken about how often this happens. I would imagine there would be more complaints if it did! Hope the hand has heal completely!

ArtsyOne 08-21-2012 07:36 AM

Thanks for posting this update - I'd been wondering what Rowenta was going to say about your experience. And it makes me more diligent about checking my cords too.

RonieM 08-21-2012 07:42 AM

I have been using the same Rowenta iron for over 10 years and have never had a problem with it. I would say your's was probably just a fluke.

Congrats on your blue ribbon!

Deborahlees 08-21-2012 07:42 AM

I would persue the Product safety council with zeal...this could be a major home/life safety issue, what if you had died and your house had burned down, then what would they have to say !!!!!

crafty pat 08-21-2012 07:47 AM

That is the iron I have so like you I am a little afraid to use it. I have never had any problems with it but I have been using it a long time so maybe I need to have the cord checked out or get a new iron. I am so happy your quilt won for you.

DogHouseMom 08-21-2012 07:54 AM

I'm stunned that an employee of Rowenta would say that (no- I don't doubt what you heard, I am just scratching my head that he would SAY those words). Basically - he freely admitted that Rowenta has a safety issue that has been known for a long time ... HUGE product liability!!!

I would definitely pursue this with Product Safety Council as there are other people out there with this product that might not be as lucky as you - they could lose their homes or ... their lives.

Patti25314 08-21-2012 08:50 AM

I think you should pursue reimbursement for your fabric and any medical bills. I had a problem once with dog medication (can't reveal name of company - part of the settlement), but they paid for ALL of my dogs medical costs which covered about 3 months of care. Rowenta make such great irons that I can't imagine that they don't want to make this right and make you a happy customer.

ptquilts 08-21-2012 08:54 AM

I have been ironing for 45 years (no Rowentas) and have never had one burst into flame. Reminds me of when you take your car in for a problem, no matter what it is, the answer is always, "They're known for that."

If this happens so much, why don't they FIX it!!!!

I would use the new iron and the other Rowentas, but always unplug them when I left the room.

Peckish 08-21-2012 08:59 AM


Originally Posted by DogHouseMom (Post 5456609)
Basically - he freely admitted that Rowenta has a safety issue that has been known for a long time ... HUGE product liability!!!

This is EXACTLY what I was thinking. That employee just opened Rowenta up for legal action. Well, this solidifies MY decision to stay away from them.

Peckish 08-21-2012 09:14 AM

To answer your question - I have a Reliable Velocity iron that I adore. It was given to me by a good friend who has one and loves it so much she got one for me. I highly recommend it.

QuiltingCrazie 08-21-2012 09:18 AM

Glad your ok...that's nuts!! I stopped using Rowenta irons because of the leakage problems.

chips88 08-21-2012 09:24 AM

employee maybe fired by now.. ya think?

sweet 08-21-2012 09:27 AM

WOW. I am happy for you about your ribbon! I am shocked about your ordeal with Rowenta. Actually, shocked is a little understated. I do not approve at all of the way you were treated. Thank you for posting.

MattieMae 08-21-2012 09:32 AM

I don’t have a Rowenta travel iron like yours that caught fire. I think I bought my Rowenta DA 82.3 and DE 92.1 back in the 90’s. My daughter and I have used them both extensively. One of them now spits, so it is only used dry.

We are very careful to not use them with power strips, extension cords or timers. They heat up quickly, produce lots of steam, have a nice long swivel cord, and no automatic shut off. We will definitely keep a sharp eye on them from now on. We also keep several fire extinguishers scattered throughout the house.

Thanks for sharing your experience and congratulations on the ribbon. I bet his statement about irons shorting out was about irons in general, not specifically Rowenta irons. I would contact the Product Safety Council as advised.



sewmary 08-21-2012 11:52 AM

Unless you recorded the conversation with the Rowenta employee, it will be a case of he said-she said. You can't prove that is what was said.

Also, you should report it to Product Safety but I think you should never have sent the iron itself back to Rowenta. You now have lost your only proof of what happened.

I am a real cynic when it comes to working with corporations. Do not expect them to do the right thing unless they are forced to. If this iron is a real hazard, it should be recalled.

As for the new iron - there is no way I would use it.

nativetexan 08-21-2012 12:45 PM

No, don't use the iron they sent. send it back if you can. refuse it if the post office will let you.
i had mine for years and it finally blew my power strip. so lucky it didn't catch fire. i ignored everyone. no more!!

Jan in VA 08-21-2012 01:00 PM

While you still have the box the "new" Rowenta came in, check to see if it states where it was actually made/assembled. That might be an eye-opener. If the man you spoke with at Rowenta said the CORD was the problem, IF you choose to use the new one, can you have the cord replaced by a good (as in certified, trained, accountable, honest, reliable) electrician?

What a mess. SO VERY GLAD I gave up using Rowentas after the last one spit at me one time too many and all the reviews I read online bashed the brand soundly. I bought a $20+/- Black and Decker from WM and will just toss and buy a new one it when it begins to misbehave.

Maybe you can save someone from a major hurt by posting your experience on one of the consumer review sites for Rowenta on line, too.

Jan in VA

Lori S 08-21-2012 01:24 PM

I had a similiar experience with two Rowenta 's ( I thought the first was just a fluke, and bought a second). It just kept heating and heating till it was beyond white hot and still kept heating, I hate to think what would have happened had I not realized what was happening.
I am glad you are OK, the companies response was a bit lame( in my opinion). Congrats on the quilt.

mrodarme 08-21-2012 01:59 PM

i just put a rowenta iron in the trash last week....i was doing quite a bit of ironing, tops & back to go to the quilter...i went & pulled out the cord & the plug was HOT!!!!...i thought maybe i just was running it too long & too high....the next day i switched to my shark, same amt of ironing time...the plug was cool when i pulled it out...tried my rowenta again in another plug; same thing...very hot to the touch....i decided it wasnt worth it...i did inspect the cord, no cracks, opening, bends, etc...i wont get another...its not worth the risk...shame on rowenta for their carefree attitude...i wonder their reply if it was their house that burned.....monica in texas

LadyElisabeth 08-21-2012 02:06 PM

I was thinking about getting a Rowenta, but think I will try something else

sewmuch 08-21-2012 02:11 PM

YIPPEE, on your blue ribbon....I have had the same Rowenta for 15 years, no problems, but will certainly check the cord...also, have 2 sunbeams no problems with them either...

momto5 08-21-2012 03:35 PM


Originally Posted by RonieM (Post 5456582)
I have been using the same Rowenta iron for over 10 years and have never had a problem with it. I would say your's was probably just a fluke.

Congrats on your blue ribbon!

No, I would say YOURS was the fluke...there are many people on this Board (me included) who have had problems with the Rowentas...to the point where I, at least, will NEVER buy another one...I've had three, and had problems with all of them. None of them hold water in addition to being what looks like a fire hazard. They need to pull them off the market! :) And it's not like they're inexpensive...

spokanequilter 08-21-2012 03:45 PM

Wow - I hadn't read anything about this until now. Scary for sure... I've had two Rowentas, paid about $100 for each, and finally after the second one started spitting and leaking, I went to Walmart and bought a T-Fal for about $40 and it works like a dream. Plenty of steam, auto shut-off and a really long cord. Everything I want in an iron for a lot less money. Rowenta was recommended to me by a friend who swears by hers, but I'm re not very excited about the brand. Sounds like they have varying reliability.

I think you should definitely pursue is with the Product Safety Commission. Good luck!!

ube quilting 08-21-2012 03:50 PM

I use a Reliable and love it. A good weight and lots of steam in adjustable amounts. I use this for pressing yardage.

I really like my small travel Rowenta for pressing seams while I'm sewing.

peace

Skyangel 08-21-2012 03:55 PM

I will never buy another Rowenta iron. I bought one at Macy's and within 1 year it started leaking and by 3 years it died. One day it was sitting on the ironing board behind me as I sewed, getting up to use it periodically. Suddenly it started steaming on it's own, got hotter and hotter, them POP! and it died. Now I am using a Rowenta I bought used at a silent auction at work for $1.00 ... the sole was brown and gunky, I got some cleaner and cleaned it. When the other one died, I started using it, haven't had a problem yet, no leak ... knock on wood ... but I will get something else next time.

Stitchnripper 08-21-2012 06:21 PM

My leaky Rowenta is in a closet. I use a Black and Decker Digital Advantage

Silver Needle 08-21-2012 06:31 PM

I iron a lot with my Rowenta Travel Iron. It has that extra plastic piece that goes around the cord where it enters the iron. I see that it has split and no longer supports the cord as it enters the iron. I wonder if its getting time to replace it? Does anyone have a favorite travel iron size brand that they like other than the Rowenta?

almond 08-21-2012 06:58 PM

Hi Kay! Great job on quilt. You will need to post a picture to show off that beauty. I've seen it girls and it is wonderful!
By the way Kay, I also threw out my rowenta also.

Peckish 08-21-2012 09:03 PM


Originally Posted by Stitchnripper (Post 5457996)
My leaky Rowenta is in a closet. I use a Black and Decker Digital Advantage

The Digital Advantage is another good iron, I had one before I got the Reliable. It worked great - until I dropped it on brick. :(

Monroe 08-21-2012 09:26 PM

My 1st Rowenta was about $90 around 1997, and I only ironed some clothes weekly. About 6 months later I kept feeling like I had a fresh scratch on the underside of my wrist, but didn't see anything. Ditto the next week. Finally realized tiny copper wires I couldn't see were just barely sticking out from the cord and I was actually being mildly zapped! Rowenta was no help at all. Didn't buy another one for 10 years, and noticed there was a better cord attachment to the iron. Well, this one leaks. No more Rowentas for me! Thank you for the fire warning!

Holice 08-22-2012 03:01 AM

I would call the company again and go up the management chain. This company constantly denies there are problems with their irons. I talked with a higher level employee at a quilt show some years ago and told him what I had been hearing and he flatly told me there was no problem with their product. If you read previous posts you will see many problems. What you were told is not appropriate and for a company to say "it happens often" is not the answer Then to send a new one just covers up the problem. So.......make the call again but to higher level management.

Reba'squilts 08-22-2012 03:14 AM

I am on my third Rowenta...I have not had a fire problem. The first two just quit after about 2 years. I unplug when I leave the room after reading about the fire problem. I like the way they iron but will not buy another. Wish I knew which one was the best! Congratulation on your blue ribbon!

ptquilts 08-22-2012 03:15 AM

check out the reviews on this website - apparently "they are known for that".

http://www.consumeraffairs.com/homeowners/rowenta.html

Do I see a class action lawsuit in the future??

Debbie C 08-22-2012 03:45 AM

I would use it, but with great caution and check it often for cracks. I'm still using an iron given to me as a shower gift over 36 years ago - a Proctor Silex that just won't quit!! So much for all the fancy stuff on today's market!!

sandy l 08-22-2012 03:52 AM

Looks like the Rowenta is one of those "love/hate" relationships. I have used them for years, with never any problems. (not bragging, just stating)

calicojoan 08-22-2012 04:05 AM

Interesting how Rowenta spun the details of fault! I am on my 4th Rowenta Steam Iron, and every one of them has started to melt by the cap where you put the water in. This one is now doing the same thing, which renders them useless. I love the iron, but at almost $200 a pop, and only about 2 years use, I can't justify another one. I am in the market for a good steam iron myself, so I am interested to hear what others have to say!

nhweaver 08-22-2012 04:11 AM

My rowenta is over six years old, my cord cracked near the plug area (cracked within the first year), and my husband replaced it with a heavy duty plug replacement. He told me it was from me pulling the cord to remove it from the outlet rather than using the plug. (Yep, I am one of those people - if I am an a hurry, I yank, rather than unplug).
I try not to do it any longer.

Morag 08-22-2012 04:14 AM


Originally Posted by RonieM (Post 5456582)
I have been using the same Rowenta iron for over 10 years and have never had a problem with it. I would say your's was probably just a fluke.

Congrats on your blue ribbon!

I agree on the "fluke" and congrats on the award:)

Geri B 08-22-2012 05:09 AM

well this just seems to be another example of cheaply made items....but unfortunately the prices are not reflective of their workmanship..... I would definitely follow up with some agency about the danger in using this product....better business bureau, underwriters lab, consumers report and everyone else I could think of........I wonder if this happenedf to "old" irons??? I don't have any R irons.....GE and B&D are mfgrs of choice for me.......so far so good, but who knows when these will also do something strange.....


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 04:15 AM.