Quiltingboard Forums

Quiltingboard Forums (https://www.quiltingboard.com/)
-   Main (https://www.quiltingboard.com/main-f1/)
-   -   Why a Bernina over a Jamone Sewing machine (https://www.quiltingboard.com/main-f1/why-bernina-over-jamone-sewing-machine-t80397.html)

peaceandjoy 12-04-2010 04:47 AM


Originally Posted by PatriceJ
ist the features and factors that are important to you. then get the one that meets all or the most of those criteria within your budget. if the one you really want is outside your budget, save up some more. ;-)

Alternatively, look for a gently used one! I am really lucky to have a great Bernina store that is run by Mennonites not very far away. They take most any model on trades, so sometimes will have really nice used machines.

Also, there is a yahoo group, "Sewitsforsale" that has machines listed several times a week. That's where I got my Janome Plantinum, for about half what I would have had to pay new.

Dodie 12-04-2010 05:13 AM

I'm not sure but I have been told that Bernette is made by Janome I also agree that the Bernina is the best I have 2 Pfaffs older and the Bernina 440QE I love the stitch regulator for quilting and it's stitching is far supperior to any other machine that I have used wonderful decorative stitches

Midwestmary 12-04-2010 05:29 AM

For me, the big consideration in purchasing my sewing machine was the dealer - I chose a Bernina because of the dealer's reputation for service.

bearlea 12-04-2010 05:53 AM

I love the Bernina quality far more than the Janome but I have 2 of both...I have a Bernina 830 embroidery and a Janome 10001 embroidery...cost of Bernina was much higher but the embroidery is beyond compare and it has a much bigger embroidery field...I am actually selling my Janome....but the plus for the Janome is the embroidery module is built in to the machine...taking my Bernina is like packing the house....as far as piecing I use my Janome 3000 most of the time and its a nice sturdy machine...if I am going to a class..I take my Bernina 240...its always packed and resdy to go...I would say...compare..test drive and pay attention to customer service...my Bernina dealer has a much better customer service..the people are always willing to help...the Janome dealer that is here now won't give you the time of day unless your there to spend.....blessings

Tinabodina 12-04-2010 06:02 AM

I recently purchased a Bernina 440 QE. There are two reasons I choose Bernine. 1) The quality seems to be above all the rest and 2) the BSR. I also have a Singer QE and of course a Featherweight. I don't have to worry about lugging around my Bernina because I always take by Featherweight when I travel.
The other reasons I purchased my Bernina is the sales people were very patient with me and took their time with me much more than the Jarome people. I knew how to work the machine before I put any money on it. The people made the difference, and of course the BSR.

keesha_ont 12-04-2010 06:09 AM

I own two Janome's and a brand new Pfaff Grand Quilter. I chose Janome because the dealer is very close, however, I have not yet had to have my machines serviced. I have not test drove a bernina but in the long run I think whatever machine does what you want it to do and the price consideration is the one you should go with. They are both probably very comparable. I purchased my Janome 6600 because I wanted the needle down option for FMQ, etc. I also like the room it has, has many stitches which I will never use and it is a workhorse. Good luck with your decision.

sueisallaboutquilts 12-04-2010 06:13 AM

I don't know anything about Janome machines but I always wanted a Bernina and love mine. Never had a single problem with it.
I also love my old Singers and I have 1 noisy Kenmore that I will never part with b/c it's my first machine and my Dad bought it for me :) I put a lot of miles on that one!!

candi 12-04-2010 06:30 AM

About two years ago, I didn't know anything about sewing, quilting or sewing machines. We were working in Boise, ID for three months and my husband and I had conflicting work schedules that I had a lot of free time, I was looking for something to fill the free time I had. We happened to be staying near a quilt shop that I passed very often and noticed that they were advertising beginner quilt classes...Keep in mind I knew nothing about any of that, but I was intrigued, long story short I signed up for the class series.

I had no sewing machine, never even touched one. The teacher lent me one of her spare sewing machines to take home so I can do some work on the quilt we were working on. Imagine someone who knows nothing about anything trying to learn many tricks. Anyway, I got it figured out with a lot of help from the teacher and the hubby.

That machine was an older Bernina, I can't remember the model.
I finished my quilt top on that machine, put the top away, and gave the machine back.

A little over a year later, I decided that I want to get back to quilting and purchase my own machine. I started shopping around. Test drove three or four machines, I can't remember if Janome was one of them. Having nothing to compare to but that old Bernina, I was shocked by how "loud" the other machines were, and they felt very light. I thought my memory was failing me about the Bernina sewing experience, so I went to a Bernina dealer and test drove one...my husband who was with me through the whole shopping ordeal said "Get the quiet Bernina." That was that!

And for the record, that teacher must be a saint, I would never loan my Bernina to anyone, much less some girl who knew nothing about nothing when it came to sewing. :) I love my Bernina, for someone who is challenged in the sewing area, I appreciate the easy to use, sturdy and quiet machine. I could sew while my husband is sleeping in the same room. :thumbup: And I've never had a minute of trouble with it.

Mattee 12-04-2010 06:38 AM


Originally Posted by Dodie
I'm not sure but I have been told that Bernette is made by Janome I also agree that the Bernina is the best I have 2 Pfaffs older and the Bernina 440QE I love the stitch regulator for quilting and it's stitching is far supperior to any other machine that I have used wonderful decorative stitches

Bernette is made for/by (however you want to phrase it) Bernina. They are much less expensive machines. They are not as nice as Berninas, however, many people love theirs, especially as class or second machines, and they come with the same dealer classes and support as a Bernina. Most people seem to only object to them because of where they're made, which I think is a ridiculous argument. JMO

Anne Marie 12-04-2010 06:38 AM

I'm on my third Bernina in thirty years - not because I needed a new machine but because I wanted to upgrade. I always get terrific trade- in prices.I bought my first one for $400 and got $400 for it when I traded it in 20 years later.Love them!!

Anne Marie 12-04-2010 06:41 AM

I'm on my third Bernina in thirty years - not because I needed a new machine but because I wanted to upgrade. I always get terrific trade- in prices.I bought my first one for $400 and got $400 for it when I traded it in 20 years later.Love them!!

Cuilteanna 12-04-2010 06:44 AM


Originally Posted by Mattee
Most people seem to only object to them because of where they're made, which I think is a ridiculous argument. JMO

Even on Bernina lists there are debates regarding the machines that are made in Thailand now. Apparently the Activas and some of the Auroras are no longer Swiss-made, and there are regular discussions regarding the Thai factories and how tightly Bernina controls them.

Somerset Val 12-04-2010 06:52 AM

I would choose a Janome every time! I have the Janome 11000 and the Janome Horizon and couldn't live without either!

Mattee 12-04-2010 06:58 AM

That's just my point. The country of origin doesn't matter; the behavior of the manufacturer, in this case Bernina, does. I've read all sorts of claims about where Bernettes are manufactured, and people usually object to a country based solely on the nation in question, when it's really the behavior of the manucturer that matters. A manufacturer in the US could be crap if they don't care about their product, and a product in China could be the best thing since sliced bread if the manufacturer cares to do a good job.


Originally Posted by Cuilteanna

Originally Posted by Mattee
Most people seem to only object to them because of where they're made, which I think is a ridiculous argument. JMO

Even on Bernina lists there are debates regarding the machines that are made in Thailand now. Apparently the Activas and some of the Auroras are no longer Swiss-made, and there are regular discussions regarding the Thai factories and how tightly Bernina controls them.


cbridges22 12-04-2010 06:59 AM

I have a Janome QC and do love it but with that being said I could have gone with anything since I only piece.Any machine that will sew a straight line would work for me.I don't embroidery or use anything but my straight stitch.So I guess your other consideration should be what are you going to use the machine for.

Matilda 12-04-2010 06:59 AM


Originally Posted by memere9
What is your reason if you made that choice?

Cathy

I had a Bernina embroidery machine. After about 4-5 years I sold it. I would never buy a Bernina again. I have a New Home (non embroidery) machine which Janome bought out the company. I would go with Janome. I don't believe I would ever get another embroidery machine but I would like the Janome 6600.

mar32428 12-04-2010 07:12 AM

When I could afford it, I moved up to Berninas. I loved them. Then I got a lemon serger. My friend got a lemon 1630. My biggest complaint is as Bernina updates its machines, it makes it impossible for you to use the new feet etc. on your older machine. I can't afford a new Bernina every other year. I finally moved to Jenome. I have the gem for classes and the 6600 for quilting. I love the machines and as far as stitching quality, I guess I'm just not that particular. That was never one of my criterias when selecting a machine.

lindalou 12-04-2010 07:20 AM

There is a Viking Huskvarna sewing maching at an auction today. Do you think they would be any good? It's an older machine, but I would like something to take to classes and use when embroidering on my Bernina. Linda

Dodie 12-04-2010 07:22 AM

what a beautiful story and what a wonderful teacher

IrishNY 12-04-2010 07:38 AM


Originally Posted by candi
And for the record, that teacher must be a saint, I would never loan my Bernina to anyone, much less some girl who knew nothing about nothing when it came to sewing. :) I love my Bernina, for someone who is challenged in the sewing area, I appreciate the easy to use, sturdy and quiet machine. I could sew while my husband is sleeping in the same room. :thumbup: And I've never had a minute of trouble with it.

I was thinking the same thing about the teacher once I realized she had loaned you her BERNINA! I can't imagine letting it out of my sight and especially with someone I didn't know. I am not very proprietary about much but my Bernina is one of those things. I don't/can't/won't share it.

Luckily your teacher was less selfish than me. :D

OmaForFour 12-04-2010 07:41 AM

Why did you replace the Pfaff? A Pfaff dealer told me that the older Pfaffs which are all metal are the best machines out there bar none.


Originally Posted by Kas
I didn't have a Janome dealer around when I got my Bernina. So I never test drove one. I was replacing a Pfaff and had tried the Viking and wasn't impressed. So that is why I got a Bernina.


OmaForFour 12-04-2010 07:45 AM

I have a White Deluxe Precision Sewing Machine from the early 50s which is all metal. Was my Aunt's. It even has a knob to turn for regular sewing, embroidery(lowers feed dogs) and silk. It is a true workhorse!
I also have a Singer Featherweight model from 1950 which I love. It sews extremely well also and purrs like a kitten.
I am about to get a Singer treadle machine from a friend whose grammy passed on.
Since I do only quilting I don't see the need for anything else in my life right now.


Originally Posted by 117becca
i have a little Bernette - and i like it. I also have an older Singer - 40s or 50s and it is much better workhorse because it will work w/ heavier weight fabrics. I do know that the Bernette isn't designed for the real heavy duty stuff


Quilter7x 12-04-2010 07:45 AM

I have a Janome Memory Craft 9000 that I bought new about 13 years ago. The machine is very user friendly and has the features I wanted the most: knee lift lever, needle threader, low bobbin sensor and embroidery (although a very small field compared to today's machines). It has the top loading bobbin, which is nice to see how much bobbin you have left. It's a heavy machine, so I have a Jem Platinum that I take to classes. I do all my piecing on the MC 9000, it's so easy to use. This machine does OK FMQ, not great. Oiling is done at the dealer. I will keep this machine forever.

I asked my local dealer about Bernina's and he said Bernina is known for beautiful stitches, so I got a used Bernina 180E this past spring. I do all my FMQ on it and it really does live up to the reputation of doing beautiful stitches. The dealer says that front loading bobbin system makes a difference in stitching for FMQ. I’ve done very little with the embroidery unit, but it appears to do really nice embroidery and has a much bigger field than the Janome, even though they are about the same age. I do have to oil this machine.

I never thought I would get anything other than a Janome because I have had such good luck with two Janomes. Now that I have both, I can see the advantages of each and I'm very happy having both set up in the sewing room so that I can use them for their benefits.

On the Bernina foot pedal, you can tap your heel to put the needle in either the up/down position. My Janome doesn't have that. The Janome has a low bobbin sensor, my Bernina doesn't (the newer ones might). Interestingly, my hubby thinks the Janome is a better made machine (more metal), but I've heard that the Swiss made Berninas are well made.

Create a list of things you MUST have, then test drive the two brands of machines. It will make it easier to make up your mind. Good luck! :thumbup:

Crabby Patty 12-04-2010 08:13 AM

Precision, stability, reliability. I have had my Bernina960 for 30 years. I got it when I was working in a fabric/altering shop then. That was what we used in the shop to make alterations. I fell in love with it and bought one. I have never been sorry. It has never had to be worked on yet.(knock on wood). I also have a Janome quilters companion which I love also. But it is not the machine that the Bernina is however it is considerably lighter.

candi 12-04-2010 08:48 AM


Originally Posted by IrishNY

Originally Posted by candi
And for the record, that teacher must be a saint, I would never loan my Bernina to anyone, much less some girl who knew nothing about nothing when it came to sewing. :) I love my Bernina, for someone who is challenged in the sewing area, I appreciate the easy to use, sturdy and quiet machine. I could sew while my husband is sleeping in the same room. :thumbup: And I've never had a minute of trouble with it.

I was thinking the same thing about the teacher once I realized she had loaned you her BERNINA! I can't imagine letting it out of my sight and especially with someone I didn't know. I am not very proprietary about much but my Bernina is one of those things. I don't/can't/won't share it.

Luckily your teacher was less selfish than me. :D


I hear you and I am right there with you. :mrgreen: She said it was one of her spares. She was an awesome teacher too, and I credit her for the love I developed for quilting. If she wasn't patient and encouraging, I wouldn't have finished that first top and I wouldn't have pursued quilting any further most likely.

Promise 12-04-2010 08:55 AM

My Mom had a Bernina when she lived in Europe. Loved it so much she hauled it to the USA and used it with a converted for over 20 years. Then she upgraded to another Bernina and has the same one for over 30years. My first machine was a Bernina and I have upgraded 3 times to another Bernina. To this day they are mainly metal not plastic, the stitch quality wether you are striaght stitching or elaborate embroidery work is superior to anything on the market. Acessories are metal and there continues to be generous literature available to purchase for all types of techniques. Reliablity...both my mom and I have had our machines for years and we have each had a tuneup one time in about 20 years. That's why I stay with Bernina.

puck116 12-04-2010 09:12 AM


Originally Posted by peaceandjoy
Berninas, other than the housing, are still metal. For durability, that's a plus. However, if you will be taking the machine to classes, retreats, etc., hauling a 25+ lb. machine is a pain in the neck.

That's why my "regular" machine is a Bernina, and my "traveling" machine is a Janome.

This is the same with me. I have both. I do all my finish quilting on my Bernina, which has the BSR (Bernina Stitch Regulator). Also, absolutely no hesitation going over multiple seams with the Bernina.

kellen46 12-04-2010 09:36 AM


Originally Posted by pvquilter
I am a "Bernina" woman. I have used them all my sewing years, Tried a Janome once. It was OK but did not compare. Love my Bernina.

You speak the truth. I am also a Bernina woman. I have used and did own a Janome once. The Bernina sews like a dream, even my, now semi-retired, old 830 mechanical. I always say if you are going to get one machine, then make it a Bernina. It is better to pay a bit more for a really good machine that will last as long as you than to buy several cheapo's that are no fun to sew on. That is just penny wise and pound foolish. I do amit to a secret love for an old 1950's Nelco I found at the thrift shop for $20, but I passed it on to a young sewer for a starter machine.

tall2 12-04-2010 09:51 AM

I have to go with Jonome 2, I have has my original machine-that I purchased in 1976- for $300.00 (it was a lot then) and Im still using it today--its a bugger to move, way to heavy at times. But I dont think I would trade it for the world. It will sew thru stuff without baulk at all, although it doesn't have some of the bells and whistles of the newer ones today.(every time I take it in for service the guy wants to buy it from me, Im thinking its the first one Jonome came out with- after taking over the original whites)
I have since purchased a Brother- for 1/2 of the price of the Janome, and Im not impressed. My sister loves Brother, thats the reason for me buying it, and trying it. I looked at the NEW Horizon, and drule over it really bad, but cant afford to get it just yet.

gramquilter2 12-04-2010 10:09 AM

I am a Bernina type, I do not know anything about the Janome, what I do know is I love my 2 Bernina's. I have never had any problems buying new feet for my machine, they fit and work. I also went with the Bernina over other machines because of the dealer and the classes they provided on using the machine. They are a bit heavy/large to take to classes but I do have a FW that I use for piecing on the GO. This is another link that it is what each person likes is perfect for them.

Kas 12-04-2010 10:25 AM


Originally Posted by OmaForFour
Why did you replace the Pfaff? A Pfaff dealer told me that the older Pfaffs which are all metal are the best machines out there bar none.


Originally Posted by Kas
I didn't have a Janome dealer around when I got my Bernina. So I never test drove one. I was replacing a Pfaff and had tried the Viking and wasn't impressed. So that is why I got a Bernina.


I do my own quilting and love to FMQ. My Pfaff, which I loved, started having tension problems when I FMQed. Not on the straight stitches, though. It still pieces like a dream. But I took it back to the dealer and he couldn't fix it. I took it to another reputable sewing machine repair shop and they couldn't fix it either. So I was miserable because I couldn't do any quilting, only straight stitching. Truly it was a blessing that it happened because I love my Bernina 640 and the knee lift! My old Tiptronic didn't have one. and the 640 has the flourescent light that goes in a "C" shape on three sides of the needle so you can really see what you are doing.

Kas 12-04-2010 10:30 AM


Originally Posted by mar32428
When I could afford it, I moved up to Berninas. I loved them. Then I got a lemon serger. My friend got a lemon 1630. My biggest complaint is as Bernina updates its machines, it makes it impossible for you to use the new feet etc. on your older machine. I can't afford a new Bernina every other year. I finally moved to Jenome. I have the gem for classes and the 6600 for quilting. I love the machines and as far as stitching quality, I guess I'm just not that particular. That was never one of my criterias when selecting a machine.

My Bernina dealer carries feet for several shank types. It even says on the box the feet come in which machine they are for. So the feet are available if you need them. But if you are upgrading, it seems like you wouldn't need to use your new feet on the old machine. Mine came with all the feet I need for quilting.

Mattee 12-04-2010 11:04 AM

Bernina had one time at which it changed its shanks, so the new feet don't fit on older machines, but this happened only once, and was done because the new foot design is so much nicer than the old. They don't update their foot design every couple of years; it was done once in the last several decades, maybe even century. Their feet are interchangeable between each of the machines, so if you buy a new machine, all of your feet will fit it, as long as they aren't the much older style of foot. It's like pre-1982 feet and post-1982 feet, for example (I don't know the exact year). They don't do it often, and aren't likely to have plans to do it again.


Originally Posted by mar32428
When I could afford it, I moved up to Berninas. I loved them. Then I got a lemon serger. My friend got a lemon 1630. My biggest complaint is as Bernina updates its machines, it makes it impossible for you to use the new feet etc. on your older machine. I can't afford a new Bernina every other year. I finally moved to Jenome. I have the gem for classes and the 6600 for quilting. I love the machines and as far as stitching quality, I guess I'm just not that particular. That was never one of my criterias when selecting a machine.


Candace 12-04-2010 11:27 AM

Yes, and Janome has now changed to the Accufeed feet on some machines, so one can't realistically complain about it. Manufacturers change feet, computer technology etc. and yes it makes some of our machines out dated and sometimes a challenge to find "old" parts and what not, but new technology is exciting.

mpspeedy 12-04-2010 11:43 AM

I learned to sew on my mother's featherweight. I worked for over a year at a Bernina dealer's shop where they stayed afloat by doing custom dressmaking and alterations. I not only learned a whole lot about garmet sewing and alterations but I fell in love with the Berninas we sewed on everyday. I had purchased one of the first Embroidery machines Bernina sold before I started working for the dealer. I also had purchased a beginner Bernina serger from the same dealer. The embroidery machine was actually a Brother patent and used the PES format. I later traded it up to the next higher model. In the meantime I was able to purchase a then new model 1260 sewing machine at the dealer's cost since I worked for them. That model didn't have the capacity to clock the hours used. I am still using it and it probably has thousands and thousands of hours on it. In the last year I purchased another Bernina machine that has the plastic housing. It makes it about ten pounds lighter than my 1260 and it actually has a few more decorative stitches than the older model. It cost a third of what I paid for the other machine. I had to spend a couple of extra hundred dollars to have the foot pedal upgraded and the knee bar installed. I have upgraded my Bernina serger in the last couple of years to one that threads easier. I use it almost daily when I am working on Linus quilts. In all I now possess 4 Berninas, a new Brother embroidery machine, a featherweight and an antique tredel machine. Given a choice I would grab my 1260 first if I had to leave any of my machines behind.
Note: At the time I purchased my first Bernina sewing machine I made a choice to get the 1260 because of the quality of the straight stitch. I don't like the combination machines. The ones that also do embroidery don't have a stable straight stitch because the needle housing must be able to move in so many directions. The other reason is because I hate to have to change the machine around everytime I want to either sew or embroider. I spent more money for my serger just to have the built in rolled hem capacity for the same reason.

IrishNY 12-04-2010 12:11 PM


Originally Posted by mpspeedy
I learned to sew on my mother's featherweight. I worked for over a year at a Bernina dealer's shop where they stayed afloat by doing custom dressmaking and alterations. I not only learned a whole lot about garmet sewing and alterations but I fell in love with the Berninas we sewed on everyday. I had purchased one of the first Embroidery machines Bernina sold before I started working for the dealer. I also had purchased a beginner Bernina serger from the same dealer. The embroidery machine was actually a Brother patent and used the PES format. I later traded it up to the next higher model. In the meantime I was able to purchase a then new model 1260 sewing machine at the dealer's cost since I worked for them. That model didn't have the capacity to clock the hours used. I am still using it and it probably has thousands and thousands of hours on it. In the last year I purchased another Bernina machine that has the plastic housing. It makes it about ten pounds lighter than my 1260 and it actually has a few more decorative stitches than the older model. It cost a third of what I paid for the other machine. I had to spend a couple of extra hundred dollars to have the foot pedal upgraded and the knee bar installed. I have upgraded my Bernina serger in the last couple of years to one that threads easier. I use it almost daily when I am working on Linus quilts. In all I now possess 4 Berninas, a new Brother embroidery machine, a featherweight and an antique tredel machine. Given a choice I would grab my 1260 first if I had to leave any of my machines behind.
Note: At the time I purchased my first Bernina sewing machine I made a choice to get the 1260 because of the quality of the straight stitch. I don't like the combination machines. The ones that also do embroidery don't have a stable straight stitch because the needle housing must be able to move in so many directions. The other reason is because I hate to have to change the machine around everytime I want to either sew or embroider. I spent more money for my serger just to have the built in rolled hem capacity for the same reason.

I love, love, love my 1260! :thumbup:

KLO 12-04-2010 12:11 PM

I have a Bernina 153QE that I bought second hand a few years ago from my LQS. I swore I would never buy a Bernina but I was sewing on an old Singer that was giving me trouble. The owner of the shop said for years that he was going to sell me a machine and finally did. Well, I love this little machine. It does all and more than I could ask for. The only change I would make would be to enlarge the throat space which I gather they have done finally with a newer model. Might do a trade in for that one day.

catrancher 12-04-2010 12:19 PM

I had a bare bones Janome that I absolutely hated from the day I brought it home. It gave me nothing but trouble. When I bought one to replace it, it was a Bernina. I love my Bernina. I kept the Janome as a spare in case the Bernina ever breaks down. So far, I haven't used it.

gale 12-04-2010 12:20 PM

I wonder if you got a lemon. I've heard very little or no complaints about Janome machines.

Lucky Lindy 12-04-2010 12:21 PM

My best friend urged me to get one about 9 years ago. She said it made sewing so much fun, I wouldn't be able to stop! Well she was right and I'm still sewing with it and loving it. I miss my friend, she passed away 2 years ago from cancer, but I think of her everyday when I sit down to sew....maybe I should name my machine Lynette, after my friend!


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 10:05 PM.