How about your local 'merchandiser' paper. Most places do have a local paper that is just all ads for everyone's everything, that they don't want any more. Also, perhaps shipping will not be in play, since you live 'sew' close..

I'm lucky and we have a local bookstore called Mr. K's that you can trade in your books or sell them. You obviously get more trade $ than if you sell them. To me it's feels like renting because when I'm done with a book and it's not a keeper I can trade it without losing all the money I spent on it. They have more romance novels than anything else but they take any and all kinds.

We had a tragedy occur in our community due to a Craigslist scam. The fire department is now where sellers are welcome for transactions.

You might check the books you want to sell on Amazon -- sometimes they offer more money if you are willing to send them your book, depending on what the books are going for and how hard they are to find.