Mona G I like them both thank you, I love the swirl fabric in the second one.

For the fish blocks I like 4 best or 2 also.

Mona great feather block, I love the colors you put in it.
silly me I thought the fish block was two different blocks, I like it with the fish in the corners, but the square in square is just as beautiful as the star, can't choose.

I'd go with number 2 because you have more of the focal fabric

Our house is wild, oldest dd is here from Texas, # 2 dd, her dh and son are here from Wisconsin and my son is here from Las Vegas. They are all going to the Minnesota Vikings first game in their new stadium. You can tell we are a football family. Only dd# 3 Doesn't like the sport. They all left to head downtown for the game and suddenly the house is quiet again.

LOVE that star block, GramE! You are amazing.

Sewbizgirl, I just follow the dotted line. I print the pattern on the fabric. But, thanks, I like this block too!

I like 2 or 4 best. ALL are great but 2 or 4 are lighter and make the fish stand out! Thanks for going to so much trouble!

I like 2 or 4 better also, uses more of the focus fabric. Personally I like stars so would like #4

I vote 2 or 4,but they are all GREAT!!

OK, it looks like #2 wins....thanks for your help.

Great choice. Love it when our fabrics are the standouts.