I AGREE, THE ONE ON THE RIGHT WITH THE POOKA DOTS REALLY POPS IT OUT.

Dots.

I think they are both nice and either would work, but as someone said earlier if you are going to embroider the outside border I would stick with the solid, you don't want it to take away from the embroidery.
Muriel

I like the one on the left.

I like the dots on the right.

I vote the black with stars

I like the right side.

I vote for the dark brown on the left.

I like the one on the right.

My vote is for the one on the right.