Carpenter's Star quilts I'm working on...
 

I like how the second one turned out but unsure about the first one..what do you think..

No picture.. can't wait to see it.

I like the first one as well as the second one . They are both very pretty. Good job.

sassy granny

I think they are both great!!! Once they are quilted, you will really see them come to life. congratulations on two beautiful quilts.

Both are very pretty, especially like the first one, it is very striking!

I like tthe colors on both of them.

I love them both! Great job.

I love them both, more partial to the darker green perhaps.

I lean toward the first. But your work is beautiful!

I like the first one best myself.

Oh boy. I love the carpenter star. Your first one is really bright and sassy. Like it

very nice!

I just printed this pattern 9 days ago that I saw here on the quilting board. After seeing yours I'm anxious to start one, they look 3 dimentional, I love both of them.

Personally, the 1st one is my favorite, but good job on both!

I love the first one. So bright and cheerful!

I'll take it!!! i like the 1st one better!!!

I love them both, they are beautiful!!!!

I also like the first one best, we all have different color tastes, which that is why we are all unique!

actually like the first one best !

I like both quilts. You did a great job.

I really like the first one

I particularly like the lime green one. It has a lot of spunk!

I see what you mean. The colors you chose for the second one give it depth. There's nothing wrong with the first, but I also prefer the second. Nice job.

Both are great!!

Think I'm going to make a few of these sized down to 36" and donate them to the special care nursery in the hospital where I work. I recently saw tutorials how to make 1/2 square triangles and will try it with this. Thank you for the inspiration!

I like the first one, very spring-ie.

Thank you all for your input...you have no idea how much it helps....

Like them both.I would like to make one but perhaps I would choose a not so blah background.or is that how the picture took.....

I like them both. love making this pattern

Both quilts look great!

Like the first one better than the second on, but thats just me. I'm not much into dark colors except for black. Beautiful ojb on both though.

They are both very nice. I haven't tried that pattern yet, but it is a favorite to look at.

I am also working on a Carpenter Star, but no pattern just following a pic and doing a double ring...It's amazing how they all look different by all the color combinations.

I like the Carpenter's Wheel with the the brighter green best, but the darker one would be ideal for a lot do guys.

I'm in love with the first one.The second one in beautiful ,but the first one in over the top.Sandy

I love the first one!!! I have a thing for bright colors though :) I really like the second to, it has more of a country feel to it, to me anyway. Great work on both they are wonderful.

Love the first one! The second one is good, but it has less interest for me because it's two colors only. I like exciting quilts! :D

I like the first one the best. I like the contrast better. You can see the difference in the colors better. Both are beautiful. Please post finished pictures.

Love the first one!!!! I am a brights person :)