My vote is for the 1st one. The 2nd looks too plain

First one.

You get a totally different look with number 2, the number one shows the stars better which I think is the strongest pattern.:)

I like to colored center stars. They really pop.

Susan

I like the first one the best unless you are going to feature some embroidery or fancy quilting in the blocks of the second one.
Lisa

I love the colored stars! I love your pattern!

First one for me too

I thing the colored centers look best.

I like number 1 .... the stars pop!

I am drawn to the 2nd one. I can't say why. I do like both of them and it would be hard for me to decide too.