I like the compromise one also, after that I like #3.

I like number 3 the best then 1 then 2 I really like them all

I like this one best of all

1st one is a strong heavier border.
2nd feels lighter, softer.
3rd seems a perfect balance for a delicate beautiful quilt.
But, any of them would look beautiful.

At first I liked #1 better, but I actually like your compromise the best.

I like the 1st one and thank you for sharing
Have a Blessed day
Ellen

I like #1. Just saw the compromise and I liked that one too.

I like #3. It looks delicate like the center. It makes it look light and airy.

I'm tied between the compromise and #3. The quilt is very beautiful.

I like the third choice. The double border...really frames the star without overpowering it. The first border seems too heavy to me and the second alternative seems unfinished. Really pretty!