I am so sorry that I am no use at helping you to make the decision because I like them all! Let us know what you decided to use as a border, I'll be interested to know. :)

I like the compromise

I will go with third, but each looks nice

Oooh I like #3

You hit the jackpot with the forth one. I was going to say three, but then saw the forth one and liked it the best.

Beautiful design, intricate but airy. I think number 3 really sets off the central design without overwhelming it. I'm looking forward to seeing the finished project.

#1 and then #3, should be beautiful.

Wow, this is tough I thought I liked #1 best but now I think it's #3.

The #3rd one. It just makes it look so dainty. It is such a beautiful quilt. You did a beautiful job. Love your choice of colors. So neat looking. gorgeous!!!!

I like 3 but what about using a red and blue rather than 2 blue on the outside or maybe bind it with a red. Nonetheless it is very pretty.