Both are great fabrics, but I think the one on the left, being more subtle and with an overall design, will play a better supporting role for those cute cats. Adorable quilt. Great job!

.i like both choices in fact i might be tempted to use both of them One border on top and side and the other border fabric bottom and other side.

I think the cats can stand the one on the right. Cute quilt!

I like them both! The one on the left I like because it matches your sashing. I liked it first. Then I looked at the first picture and saw that the one on the right is brighter. I have to say, it's up to you. When I can't decide, I lay it out where you will pass by it a cuople of times and you will be able to see which one is the best choice. It may take a couple of days though.

What a cute quilt! I like the one on the right.

I agree.

To me the right one makes the cats pop.....cute quilt, where did the pattern come from???

Left one....doesn't draw the eye away from the cats. Right one is too distracting to me.

Right is right.

I love the quilt top and both border fabrics but I do think the one on the left goes better with your cute cats. The right one, draws attention away from the cats. Will be so so cute when completed!