one more vote here for the black....makes it pop,like your color combo's pab

The black is more dramatic, I love it. The light is more soft and subtle, pretty in it's own way too :D:D:D

the darker one.

They are both nice, but I like g. Love the dark colors. Good job.

I like the dark one better too. :)

ditto on the black

I vote for the black. Both are very pretty but the black is my favorite.

I like the black really makes it pop! That is what I would go for. Gorgeous quilt.

Both are pretty but I think the one with the black makes a stronger presence. Nice very nice

I'm going against the popular vote and saying that I like the lighter one best. Maybe I'm just hoping for an early spring. lol