I'm jumping in on the bandwagon for black!

Black - it really makes the other colors pop...Sooo pretty..back to work....we want to see this one finished....

They are both beautiful, but the one with black has my vote.

My vote is for the black also

Both are lovely, but I think the first one is just a little lovelier.

I vote for the black setting.

I vote for the darker one but they both are beautiful.

I vote for the one with black in it (but the other one is very pretty as well!). You could always make one of each!

I like the black but then I like bold quilts

The black is very dramatic! I like it best.