I like the Evening Star, especially with the colors you have chosen. Very pretty.

I like the second one..I have never been a star person..Even though stars are so pretty.. Just not my taste...

I vote for the "Evening Star"..........

Definetly the star pattern..

Evening Star!

Evening Star

first one for me.

I vote for the Evening Star

I like the TOE TAP. The balance of shapes is calming even tho the colors just shout...Autumn!

The stars are pretty but the half-stars are incomplete AKA not balanced. IMHO

ditto for me!!

I love the second one but the Evening Star wins my vote. It's beautiful.

they're sewww different from each other, make both :-P

Evening Star! Its absolutely GORGEOUS!

I like the Evening Star.

I like the first one....Lone Star

I like the first one....Evening Star.....sorry

Easy-------Evening Star!

evening star...nice

For sure, the Evening Star

I like the Evening star

I love the Evening Star, but I also like Toe Tap, but I think Evening Star would be the one I would choose to do first.
I love the colours too. Have fun picking all your fabrics and I'm sure the shop hop will be a blast!

Both lovely. Star is my favorite.

I would do the 1st one - that is so pretty.

Both of them are fantastic maybe because of the colors you used but I do love the Evening Star.

I like the evening star too.

I like the star one best :) just my 2 cents worth

Wow – so many wonderful responses! I also took a poll this evening at Girl’s Nite Out (GNO) and the winner was Evening Star as well.
The Toe Tap finished size is 66x66. The original pattern had it as 46x66, but I added another two “columns” to make it square (for some reason I just don’t like non-square quilts – very odd!!). The Evening Star finished size is 74x74. The original pattern had it at 54x54, but I wanted it bigger.
I am going to make the Evening Star in this color combo, but to the folks who liked the Toe Tap – don’t despair. I will make it at some point. It has been on my favorites list for a while and I really like it. It may be the one after Evening Star!
Thanks for all the responses and votes! I’ll post a pic when I get the top done and then another when I’ve finished quilting it. I’ve already started planning the quilting part – this pattern really lends itself to some neat quilting. I’m so jazzed to start! It’s killing me to wait, but I have some Christmas gifts to finish first.

Star

I love the evening star also.

Definitely the evening star, beautiful pattern!

I would go witht the evening star as it really pops.

the Evening Star is a lovely quilt ... looking forward to seeing what you decide!

The Evening Star is my favorite - love the colors, also.

Evening Star does it for me.

Evening Star. Great colors!! I love star patterns.