I'm still convinced it's cut on the wrong grain line (i.e., not the same as, meaning perpendicular to, the others). If that's so, removing it and turning it over won't make any difference at all...none, nada, zip...only a matching grain piece will appear the same color. I have 7 shades of Kona gray, they all act that way...as do all the other colors. Perhaps the OP will be back after the holiday and let us know her decision and the outcome.
