Some things my kids in that age range appreciate--
-gourmet coffee samples
-body scrub
-lint rollers (to keep in car to get dog hair off)
-tools (when they moved out on their own: hammer/screwdriver/tape measure)
-Hot Hands handwarmers and toewarmers
-movie passes
-earrings
-beef jerky
-ice scraper for car
-gift card for fast food, coffee shop, Ama---, auto shop
-thick socks