I probably would have taken him to the store with his piggy bank and made him purchase another toy for his brother so he would see how much things cost and that you shouldn't break things just because you are angry. If he didn't have that much money, then I would have made him work for the rest by doing chores for you and your hubby until the amount of the purchase was satisfied. We don't make our kids accountable for their actions and that makes them rotten!