Fons and Porter did something similar 6 or more months ago. They sent a CD, said you could pay for it, return it in the postage paid envelope or keep it since I didn't order it. I threw away the PP envelope and kept the CD. Still haven't even looked at the CD so don't even know what is on it. However, after that I continued to get a bill for the CD or request to return it in the PP envelope (which I had thrown away). I just continue tossing the new mailings. If you didn't order it, then you don't owe anything for it and don't have to return it. Yes, I agree that it is VERY POOR MARKETING. Needless to say, I am not renewing my F&P subscription as I don't care for that practice. Further, I haven't found their magazine interesting/helpful/inspirational in a while so definitly have no qualms for not renewing.