Thanks so much for your detailed explaination of the difference between the authors. Yours is the best description I have found. Very helpful.
Originally Posted by k3n
Originally Posted by Dee Dee
Well, you have certainly made some gorgeous quilts. Did you use Maxine Rosenthal book patterns for those? Should I begin with one of her books, or is it best to begin with Stack-n-Whack or Stacknwhacipedia to learn the technique?
Thank you! In fact all the quilts I have made have been from the Maxine Rosenthal books, except for a couple of generic kaleidoscopes that I just kind of winged! The fabric choice, layering, cutting etc is about the same in both books. It's the layouts that differ. If you want to do OBW, definitely get one of those books. IMO most ppl go wrong at the design stage and there are lots of tips in the books to set you on the right path to producing your layout! The OBW books are more technique-oriented - it is much more a process than a book saying 'to get a quilt this size and shape, take 5 yards of fabric A and 4 yards of fabric B and do this etc...'
On the other hand if you like the idea of doing hexes, squares, fans, diamonds etc, all with sashing between the blocks and specific patterns giving yardage requirements, finished size of quilt etc, go for the Reynolds book.
Or like amma said, try to bag a bargain and get them all! Amazon often has books listed 'used' that are hardly touched - I get a lot of mine that way! :D