I have watched American Idol almost every year that they have had it on...some years more intensely than others depending on the talent offered. I believe this year they have the most talent ever in their top nine, and someone has to go! I was a little surprised at America's choice, but then I look at it this way....she is a super talent for sure and someone WILL take her and run with her and since she won't be the "American Idol" she won't have to share any of her wealth with the owners/producers. It might take her a little longer, but she will get there!
When one of my favorites get voted off I think to myself -- well, Judi, did you pick up the phone and vote? LOL...and then I find I can't complain too much. :oops:
I would have had a hard time picking someone to go home myself....