I hadn't read all the messages before I posted so I'll add another 2 cents. I agree regarding Constantine and Iggy Pop. If you've got to beep the lyrics then they have no business being on Idol, what a Freak! Constantine sounded worse than when he was on Idol. Jennifer Hudson was not my favorite when she was on Idol; I thought she had alot of maturing to do. She's turned into a multi-talented professional with grace. Daughtery was also a favorite and I knew not winning Idol was not a deal-breaker. I hope this is not the last we hear of Pia.