I had a very similar thing happen to me. Three of the quilts that I have donated have pulled 500-700 in raffles and live auctions.
This one group asked me for something. I gave them a baby quilt with a coordinating wallhanging plus 100 dollars of baby themed goodies. Well they were obviously disappointed and threw the stuff in a basket not even displaying the quilts even though I had provided ribbons and decorative paper to help them display it.
They got peanuts about 25 dollars. It was their own fault. I will not give to them again.