Yes, I think you either like a thimble or you don't. I can't hand sew anything without one. I have one that was my grandmother's and it's so nice and smooth on the inside and fits pefectly, I almost forget I have it on. If I had to use some of the ridged ones that are sold inexpensively, it probably would bother me too. Look for ones at estate sales or antique store that are worn and smooth - it might make a differnce!