There seems to be two key issues here - one is what is and isn't appropriate and how to handle the inappropriate and the second, how the board is organised.
In an ideal world, the first issue should self-regulate but this isn't an ideal world so I think the bottom line is policing. I disagree with the 3 strikes idea preventing ppl from posting. I already KNOW that if I post foul language or am insulting to other board members, there's a chance I'll be banned - doesn't stop me from posting. I agree with KLue that most of the rules are already there - they just need to be enforced.
As to the organisation of the board, I agree that maybe PDA IS the place for the negative stuff. But all the other non-quilting topics - gardens, places ppl live, pets etc, I think still belong in GCC. I just took a look there and a huge percentage is ONLY jokes and links to funnies on the internet. There's no balance at all now! Could I have some feedback on the idea of a single café for banter and ramblings? Thanks. :D
BTW thanks so much for agreeing to Mare Stare staying in GCC. :D