I prefer frames or a hoop, but the type of thimble for me is very important. I like the kind that has a little ridge on the end, as this keeps the needle from slipping off. I learned from a lady that hand quilted like a machine. She was amazing, and she inspired me. She encouraged me to use a thimble, and personally I couldn't hand quilt without one now. It was not easy at first, but with practice it got easier.