My experience is mixed as well. I donate to my church and adjoining school. The fall church fundraiser doesn't raise as much as the winter school auction. I have learned to donate different types of items depending on the fundraiser. I also make small items for auctions for individuals to help cover medical costs. These always go for more than my cost of materials, but not outrageously high. Yes I will continue to donate, but will be careful in selecting what I give.