Our 1st grandchild is 4 months old. When I offered to make a quilt for him, DDL agreed & sent me pictures of the nursery she had in mind. From what I've seen, modern baby quilts are not what you would think of. I think either one of your tops would be awesome for a modern nursery. Unless you have a dyed-in-the-wool traditionalist, check with Mom-to-be & see what she thinks. By the way, congratulations!