I do like their show and watch it every now and then. What they do is promote what a buyers market would purchase and I believe it's age-group specific.
I too have oak cabinets and I am sick of them. Not that I want white but I would love to update them. Our house is 13-years-old and they are the builders-grade cabinets. I would do some other wood or a finer grade oak a little darker if doing it again.
They were more looking at the color/style of the quilt - they are far more contemporary and obviously gear it towards what makes rating.