I come in at the non-sentimental value side. Once a quilt is given, it no longer belongs to you, so I also would rather the recipient regift or donate a quilt, than stuff it in a closet. I would also prefer they regift it than use it for a drop cloth or give it to the dog, but it is theirs to do with as they please. I don't usually make quilts specifically as gifts. I like the quilting process, make the quilt, have it hanging around my house and when someone sees it & comments positively, they often leave the house with it.