Thanks for all the suggestions.
I'll try the soap since I have that at the house. I'll also try using tissue paper since I have that.
I'm hand quilting the entire quilt so I don't know how the paper will hold up but it's worth a try. I tried using Press n Seal last night but the design didn't show up on that either.
I tried the regular pencil but it doesn't show up on the dark fabric.
This has proven to be a bigger challenge than quilting. LOL